Thursday, 17 February 2011 23:33

Diagnosis

The diagnosis of neurotoxic disease is not easy. The errors are usually of two types: either it is not recognized that a neurotoxic agent is the cause of neurological symptoms, or neurological (and especially neurobehavioural) symptoms are erroneously diagnosed as resulting from an occupational, neurotoxic exposure. Both of these errors can be hazardous since an early diagnosis is important in the case of neurotoxic disease, and the best treatment is avoiding further exposure for the individual case and the surveillance of the condition of other workers in order to prevent their exposure to the same danger. On the other hand, sometimes undue alarm can develop in the workplace if a worker claims to have serious symptoms and suspects a chemical exposure as the cause but in fact, either the worker is mistaken or the hazard is not actually present for others. There is practical reason for correct diagnostic procedures, as well, since in many countries, the diagnosis and treatment of occupational diseases and the loss of working capacity and invalidity caused by those diseases are covered by insurance; thus the financial compensation may be disputed, if the diagnostic criteria are not solid. An example of a decision tree for neurological assessment is given in Table 1.


Table 1. Decision tree for neurotoxic disease

I. Relevant exposure level, length and type

II. Appropriate symptoms insidiously increasing central (CNS) or peripheral (PNS) nervous system symptoms

III. Signs and additional tests CNS dysfunction: neurology, psychology tests PNS dysfunction: quantitative sensory test, nerve conduction studies

IV. Other diseases excluded in differential diagnosis


Exposure and Symptoms

Acute neurotoxic syndromes occur mainly in accidental situations, when workers are exposed short-term to very high levels of a chemical or to a mixture of chemicals generally through inhalation. The usual symptoms are vertigo, malaise and possible loss of consciousness as a result of depression of the central nervous system. When the subject is removed from the exposure, the symptoms disappear rather quickly, unless the exposure has been so intense that it is life-threatening, in which case coma and death may follow. In these situations recognition of the hazard must occur at the workplace, and the victim should be taken out into the fresh air immediately.

In general, neurotoxic symptoms arise after short-term or long-term exposures, and often at relatively low-level occupational exposure levels. In these cases acute symptoms may have occurred at work, but the presence of acute symptoms is not necessary for diagnosis of chronic toxic encephalopathy or toxic neuropathy to be made. However, patients do often report headache, light-headedness or mucosal irritation at the end of a working day, but these symptoms initially disappear during the night, weekend or vacation. A useful checklist can be found in Table 2.

Table 2. Consistent neuro-functional effects of worksite exposures to some leading neurotoxic substances

 

Mixed organic solvents

Carbon disulphide

Styrene

Organophos-
phates

Lead

Mercury

Acquisition

+




+


Affect

+


+


+


Categorization

+






Coding

+

+



+

+

Colour vision

+


+




Concept shifting

+






Distractibility





+


Intelligence

+

+


+

+

+

Memory

+

+

+

+

+

+

Motor coordination

+

+

+


+

+

Motor speed

+

+

+


+

+

Near visual contrast sensitivity

+






Odour perception threshold

+






Odour identification

+




+


Personality

+

+




+

Spatial relations

+

+



+


Vibrotactile threshold

+



+


+

Vigilance

+

+



+


Visual field





+

+

Vocabulary





+


Source: Adapted from Anger 1990.

Assuming that the patient has been exposed to neurotoxic chemicals, the diagnosis of neurotoxic disease starts with symptoms. In 1985, a joint working group of the World Health Organization and the Nordic Council of Ministers discussed the matter of chronic organic solvent intoxication and found a set of core symptoms, which are found in most cases (WHO/Nordic Council 1985). The core symptoms are fatigability, memory loss, difficulties in concentration, and loss of initiative. These symptoms usually start after a basic change in personality, which develops gradually and affects energy, intellect, emotion and motivation. Among other symptoms of chronic toxic encephalopathy are depression, dysphoria, emotional lability, headache, irritability, sleep disturbances and dizziness (vertigo). If there is also involvement of the peripheral nervous system, numbness and possibly muscular weakness develop. Such chronic symptoms last for at least a year after the exposure itself has ended.

Clinical Examination and Testing

The clinical examination should include a neurological examination, where attention should be paid to impairment of higher nervous functions, such as memory, cognition, reasoning and emotion; to impaired cerebellar functions, like tremor, gait, station and coordination; and to peripheral nervous functions, especially vibration sensitivity and other tests of sensation. Psychological tests can provide objective measures of higher nervous system functions, including psychomotor, short-term memory, verbal and non-verbal reasoning and perceptual functions. In individual diagnosis the tests should include some tests that give a clue as to the person’s premorbid intellectual level. History of school performance and previous job performance as well as possible psychological tests administered previously, for example in connection with military service, can help in the evaluation of the person’s normal level of performance.

The peripheral nervous system can be studied with quantitative tests of sensory modalities, vibration and thermosensibility. Nerve conduction velocity studies and electromyography can often reveal neuropathy at an early stage. In these tests special emphasis should be on sensory nerve functions. The amplitude of the sensory action potential (SNAP) decreases more often than the sensory conduction velocity in axonal neuropathies, and most toxic neuropathies are axonal in character. Neuroradiological studies such as computed tomography (CT) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) usually do not reveal anything pertinent to chronic toxic encephalopathy, but they may be useful in the differential diagnosis.

In the differential diagnosis other neurological and psychiatric diseases should be considered. Dementia of other aetiology should be ruled out, as well as depression and stress symptoms of various causes. Psychiatric consultation may be necessary. Alcohol abuse is a relevant confounding factor; excessive use of alcohol causes symptoms similar to those of solvent exposure, and on the other hand there are papers indicating that solvent exposure may induce alcohol abuse. Other causes for neuropathy also have to be ruled out, especially entrapment neuropathies, diabetes and kidney disease; also alcohol causes neuropathy. The combination of encephalopathy and neuropathy is more likely of toxic origin than either of these alone.

In the final decision the exposure should be evaluated again. Was there relevant exposure, considering the level, length and quality of exposure? Solvents are more likely to induce psycho-organic syndrome or toxic encephalopathy; hexacarbons, however, usually first cause neuropathy. Lead and some other metals cause neuropathy, although CNS involvement can be detected later on.

 

Back

Thursday, 17 February 2011 23:31

Measuring Neurotoxic Deficits

Neuro-functional Test Batteries

Sub-clinical neurologic signs and symptoms have long been noted among active workers exposed to neurotoxins; however, it is only since the mid-1960s that research efforts have focused on the development of sensitive test batteries capable of detecting subtle, mild changes that are present in the early stages of intoxication, in perceptual, psychomotor, cognitive, sensory and motor functions, and affect.

The first neurobehavioural test battery for use in worksite studies was developed by Helena Hänninen, a pioneer in the field of neurobehavioural deficits associated with toxic exposure (Hänninen Test Battery) (Hänninen and Lindstrom 1979). Since then, there have been worldwide efforts to develop, refine and, in some cases, computerize neurobehavioural test batteries. Anger (1990) describes five worksite neurobehavioural test batteries from Australia, Sweden, Britain, Finland and the United States, as well as two neurotoxic screening batteries from the United States, that have been used in studies of neurotoxin-exposed workers. In addition, the computerized Neurobehavioral Evaluation System (NES) and the Swedish Performance Evaluation System (SPES) have been extensively used around the world. There are also test batteries designed to assess sensory functions, including measures of vision, vibrotactile perception threshold, smell, hearing and sway (Mergler 1995). Studies of various neurotoxic agents using one or another of these batteries have greatly contributed to our knowledge of early neurotoxic impairment; however, cross-study comparisons have been difficult since different tests are used and tests with similar names may be administered using a different protocol.

In an attempt to standardize information from studies on neurotoxic substances, the notion of a “core” battery was put forward by a working committee of the World Health Organization (WHO) (Johnson 1987). Based on knowledge at the time of the meeting (1985), a series of tests were selected to make up the Neurobehavioral Core Test Battery (NCTB), a relatively inexpensive, hand-administered battery, which has been successfully used in many countries (Anger et al. 1993). The tests that make up this battery were chosen to cover specific nervous system domains, which had been previously shown to be sensitive to neurotoxic damage. A more recent core battery, which comprises both hand-administered and computerized tests, has been proposed by a workgroup of the United States Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (Hutchison et al. 1992). Both batteries are presented in Table 1.

Table 1. Examples of "core" batteries for assessment of early neurotoxic effects

Neurobehavioural Core Test Battery (NCTB)+

Test order

Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry Adult Environmental Neurobehavioural Test Battery (AENTB)+

Functional domain

Test

 

Functional domain

Test

Motor steadiness

Aiming (Pursuit Aiming II)

1

Vision

Visual acuity, near contrast sensitivity

Attention/response speed

Simple Reaction Time

2

 

Colour vision (Lanthony D-15 desaturated test)

Perceptual motor speed

Digit Symbol (WAIS-R)

3

Somatosensory

Vibrotactile perception threshold

Manual dexterity

Santa Ana (Helsinki Version)

4

Motor strength

Dynamometer (including fatigue assessment)

Visual perception/memory

Benton Visual Retention

5

Motor coordination

Santa Ana

Auditory memory

Digit Span (WAIS-R, WMS)

6

Higher intellectual function

Raven Progressive Matrices (Revised)

Affect

POMS (Profile of Mood States)

7

Motor coordination

Fingertapping Test (one hand)1

   

8

Sustained attention (cognitive), speed (motor)

Simple Reaction Time (SRT) (extended)1

   

9

Cognitive coding

Symbol-digit with delayed recall1

   

10

Learning and memory

Serial Digit Learning1

   

11

Index of educational level

Vocabulary1

   

12

Mood

Mood Scale1

1 Available in computerized version; WAIS = Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale; WMS = Wechsler Memory Scale.

 

The authors of both core batteries stress that, although the batteries are useful to standardize results, they by no means provide complete assessment of nervous system functions. Additional tests should be used depending upon the type of exposure; for example, a test battery to assess nervous system dysfunction among manganese-exposed workers would include more tests of motor functions, particularly those that require rapid alternating movements, while one for methylmercury-exposed workers would include visual field testing. The choice of tests for any particular workplace should be made on the basis of current knowledge on the action of the particular toxin or toxins to which the persons are exposed.

More sophisticated test batteries, administered and interpreted by trained psychologists, are an important part of the clinical assessment for neurotoxic poisoning (Hart 1988). It includes tests of intellectual ability, attention, concentration and orientation, memory, visuo-perceptive, constructive and motor skills, language, conceptual and executive functions, and psychological well-being, as well as an assessment of possible malingering. The profile of the patient’s performance is examined in the light of past and present medical and psychological history, as well as exposure history. The final diagnosis is based on a constellation of deficits interpreted in relation to the type of exposure.

Measures of Emotional State and Personality

Studies of the effects of neurotoxic substances usually include measures of affective or personality disturbance, in the form of symptoms questionnaires, mood scales or personality indices. The NCTB, described above, includes the Profile of Mood States (POMS), a quantitative measure of mood. Using 65 qualifying adjectives of mood states over the past 8 days, the degrees of tension, depression, hostility, vigour, fatigue and confusion are derived. Most comparative workplace studies of neurotoxic exposure indicate differences between exposed and non-exposed. A recent study of styrene-exposed workers shows dose-response relations between post-shift urinary mandelic acid level, a biological indicator of styrene, and scale scores of tension, hostility, fatigue and confusion (Sassine et al. 1996).

Lengthier and more sophisticated tests of affect and personality, such as the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Index (MMPI), which reflect both emotional states and personality traits, have been used primarily for clinical evaluation, but also in workplace studies. The MMPI likewise provides an assessment of symptom exaggeration and inconsistent responses. In a study of microelectronics workers with a history of exposure to neurotoxic substances, results from the MMPI indicated clinically significant levels of depression, anxiety, somatic concerns and disturbances of thinking (Bowler et al. 1991).

Electrophysiological Measures

Electrical activity generated by the transmission of information along nerve fibres and from one cell to another, can be recorded and used in the determination of what is happening in the nervous system of persons with toxic exposures. Interference with neuronal activity can slow down transmission or modify the electrical pattern. Electrophysiological recordings require precise instruments and are most frequently carried out in a laboratory or hospital setting. There have, however, been efforts to develop more portable equipment for use in workplace studies.

Electrophysiological measures record a global response of a large number of nerve fibres and/or fibres, and a fair amount of damage must exist before it can be adequately recorded. Thus, for most neurotoxic substances, symptoms, as well as sensory, motor and cognitive changes, usually can be detected in groups of exposed workers before electrophysiological differences are observed. For clinical examination of persons with suspected neurotoxic disorders, electrophysiological methods provide information concerning the type and extent of nervous system damage. A review of electrophysiological techniques used in the detection of early neurotoxicity in humans is provided by Seppalaïnen (1988).

The nerve conduction velocity of sensory nerves (going towards the brain) and motor nerves (going away from the brain) are measured by electroneurography (ENG). By stimulating at different anatomical positions and recording at another, the conduction velocity can be calculated. This technique can provide information about the large myelinated fibres; slowing of conduction velocity occurs when demyelination is present. Reduced conduction velocities have frequently been observed among lead-exposed workers, in the absence of neurological symptoms (Maizlish and Feo 1994). Slow conduction velocities of peripheral nerves have also been associated with other neurotoxins, such as mercury, hexacarbons, carbon disulphide, styrene, methyl-n-butyl ketone, methyl ethyl ketone, and certain solvent mixtures. The trigeminal nerve (a facial nerve) is affected by trichloroethylene exposure. However, if the toxic substance acts primarily on thinly myelinated or unmyelinated fibres, conduction velocities usually remain normal.

Electromyography (EMG) is used for measuring the electrical activity in muscles. Electromyographic abnormalities have been observed among workers with exposure to such substances as n-hexane, carbon disulphide, methyl-n-butyl ketone, mercury and certain pesticides. These changes are often accompanied by changes in ENG and symptoms of peripheral neuropathy.

Changes in brainwaves are evidenced by electroencephalography (EEG). In patients with organic solvent poisoning, local and diffuse slow wave abnormalities have been observed. Some studies report evidence of dose-related EEG alterations among active workers, with exposure to organic solvent mixtures, styrene and carbon disulphide. Organochlorine pesticides can cause epileptic seizures, with EEG abnormalities. EEG changes have been reported with long-term exposure to organophosphorus and zinc phosphide pesticides.

Evoked potentials (EP) provides another means of examining nervous system activity in response to a sensory stimulus. Recording electrodes are placed on the specific area of the brain that responds to the particular stimuli, and the latency and amplitude of the event-related slow potential are recorded. Increased latency and/or reduced peak amplitudes have been observed in response to visual, auditory and somatosensory stimuli for a wide range of neurotoxic substances.

Electrocardiography (ECG or EKG) records changes in the electrical conduction of the heart. Although it is not often used in studies of neurotoxic substances, changes in ECG waves have been observed among persons with exposure to trichloroethylene. Electro-oculographic (EOG) recordings of eye movements have shown alterations among workers with exposure to lead.

Brain Imaging Techniques

In recent years, different techniques have been developed for brain imaging. Computed tomographic (CT) images reveal the anatomy of the brain and spinal cord. They have been used to study cerebral atrophy among solvent-exposed workers and patients; however, the results are not consistent. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) examines the nervous system using a powerful magnetic field. It is particularly useful clinically to rule out an alternative diagnosis, such as brain tumours. Positron Emission Tomography (PET), which yields images of biochemical processes, has been successfully used to study changes in the brain induced by manganese intoxication. Single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) provides information about brain metabolism and may prove to be an important tool in understanding how neurotoxins act on the brain. These techniques are all very costly, and not readily available in most hospitals or laboratories throughout the world.

 

Back

Neurotoxicant syndromes, brought about by substances which adversely affect nervous tissue, constitute one of the ten leading occupational disorders in the United States. Neurotoxicant effects constitute the basis for establishing exposure limit criteria for approximately 40% of agents considered hazardous by the United States National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH).

A neurotoxin is any substance capable of interfering with the normal function of nervous tissue, causing irreversible cellular damage and/or resulting in cellular death. Depending on its particular properties, a given neurotoxin will attack selected sites or specific cellular elements of the nervous system. Those compounds, which are non-polar, have greater lipid solubility, and thus have greater access to nervous tissue than highly polar and less lipid-soluble chemicals. The type and size of cells and the various neurotransmitter systems affected in different regions of the brain, innate protective detoxifying mechanisms, as well as the integrity of cellular membranes and intracellular organelles all influence neurotoxicant responses.

Neurons (the functional cell unit of the nervous system) have a high metabolic rate and are at greatest risk for neurotoxicant damage, followed by oligodendrocytes, astrocytes, microglia and cells of the capillary endothelium. Changes in cellular membrane structure impair excitability and impede impulse transmission. Toxicant effects alter protein form, fluid content and ionic exchange capability of membranes, leading to swelling of neurons, astrocytes and damage to the delicate cells lining blood capillaries. Disruption of neurotransmitter mechanisms block access to post-synaptic receptors, produce false neurotransmitter effects, and alter the synthesis, storage, release, re-uptake or enzymatic inactivation of natural neurotransmitters. Thus, clinical manifestations of neurotoxicity are determined by a number of different factors: the physical characteristics of the neurotoxicant substance, the dose of exposure to it, the vulnerability of the cellular target, the organism’s ability to metabolize and excrete the toxin, and by the reparative abilities of the structures and mechanisms affected. Table 1 lists various chemical exposures and their neurotoxic syndromes.

Table 1. Chemical exposures and associated neurotoxic syndromes

Neurotoxin

Sources of exposure

Clinical diagnosis

Locus of pathology1

Metals

Arsenic

Pesticides; pigments; antifouling paint; electroplating industry; seafood; smelters; semiconductors

Acute: encephalopathy

Chronic: peripheral neuropathy

Unknown (a)

Axon (c)

Lead

Solder; lead shot; illicit whiskey; insecticides; auto body shop; storage battery manufacturing; foundries, smelters; lead-based paint; lead pipes

Acute: encephalopathy

Chronic: encephalopathy and peripheral neuropathy

Blood vessels (a)

Axon (c)

Manganese

Iron, steel industry; welding operations; metal-finishing operations; fertilizers; manufacturers of fireworks, matches; manufacturers of dry cell batteries

Acute: encephalopathy

Chronic: parkinsonism

Unknown (a)

Basal ganglia neurons (c)

Mercury

Scientific instruments; electrical equipment; amalgams; electroplating industry; photography; felt making

Acute: headache, nausea, onset of tremor

Chronic: ataxia, peripheral neuropathy, encephalopathy

Unknown (a)

Axon (c)

Unknown (c)

Tin

Canning industry; solder; electronic components; polyvinyl plastics; fungicides

Acute: memory defects, seizures, disorientation

Chronic: encephalomyelopathy

Neurons of the limbic system (a & c)

Myelin (c)

Solvents

Carbon disulphide

Manufacturers of viscose rayon; preservatives; textiles; rubber cement; varnishes; electroplating industry

Acute: encephalopathy

Chronic: peripheral neuropathy, parkinsonism

Unknown (a)

Axon (c)

Unknown

n-hexane,

methyl butyl ketone

Paints; lacquers; varnishes; metal-cleaning compounds; quick-drying inks; paint removers; glues, adhesives

Acute: narcosis

Chronic: peripheral neuropathy, unknown (a) Axon (c),

 

Perchloroethylene

Paint removers; degreasers; extraction agents; dry cleaning industry; textile industry

Acute: narcosis

Chronic: peripheral neuropathy, encephalopathy

Unknown (a)

Axon (c)

Unknown

Toluene

Rubber solvents; cleaning agents; glues; manufacturers of benzene; gasoline, aviation fuels; paints, paint thinners; lacquers

Acute: narcosis

Chronic: ataxia, encephalopathy

Unknown (a)

Cerebellum (c)

Unknown

Trichloroethylene

Degreasers; painting industry; varnishes; spot removers; process of decaffeination; dry cleaning industry; rubber solvents

Acute: narcosis

Chronic: encephalopathy, cranial neuropathy

Unknown (a)

Unknown (c)

Axon (c)

 Insecticides

 Organophosphates

 Agricultural industry manufacturing and application

 Acute: cholinergic poisoning

 Chronic: ataxia, paralysis, peripheral neuropathy

 Acetylcholinesterase (a)

 Long tracts of spinal cord (c)

 Axon (c)

 Carbamates

 Agricultural industry manufacturing and application flea powders

 Acute: cholinergic poisoning Chronic: tremor, peripheral neuropathy

 Acetylcholinesterase (a)

 Dopaminergic system (c)

 1 (a), acute; (c), chronic.

Source: Modified from Feldman 1990, with permission of the publisher.

 

Establishing a diagnosis of a neurotoxicant syndrome and differentiating it from neurologic diseases of non-neurotoxicant aetiology requires an understanding of the pathogenesis of the neurological symptoms and observed signs and symptoms; an awareness that particular substances are capable of affecting nervous tissue; documentation of exposure; evidence of presence of neurotoxin and/or metabolites in tissues of an affected individual; and careful delineation of a time relationship between exposure and the appearance of symptoms with subsequent decrease in symptoms after exposure is ended.

Proof that a particular substance has reached a toxicant dose level is usually lacking after symptoms appear. Unless environmental monitoring is ongoing, a high index of suspicion is necessary to recognize cases of neurotoxicologic injury. Identifying symptoms referable to the central and/or the peripheral nervous systems can help the clinician focus on certain substances, which have a greater predilection for one part or another of the nervous system, as possible culprits. Convulsions, weakness, tremor/twitching, anorexia (weight loss), equilibrium disturbance, central nervous system depression, narcosis (a state of stupor or unconsciousness), visual disturbance, sleep disturbance, ataxia (inability to coordinate voluntary muscle movements), fatigue and tactile disorders are commonly reported symptoms following exposure to certain chemicals. Constellations of symptoms form syndromes associated with neurotoxicant exposure.

Behavioural Syndromes

Disorders with predominantly behavioural features ranging from acute psychosis, depression and chronic apathy have been described in some workers. It is essential to differentiate memory impairment associated with other neurological diseases, such as Alzheimer’s disease, arteriosclerosis or presence of a brain tumour, from the cognitive deficits associated with toxicant exposure to organic solvents, metals or insecticides. Transient disturbances of awareness or epileptic seizures with or without associated motor involvement must be identified as a primary diagnosis separate from similarly appearing disturbances of consciousness related to neurotoxicant effects. Subjective and behavioural toxicant syndromes such as headache, vertigo, fatigue and personality change manifest as mild encephalopathy with inebriation, and may indicate the presence of exposure to carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, lead, zinc, nitrates or mixed organic solvents. Standardized neuropsychological testing is necessary to document elements of cognitive impairment in patients suspected of toxicant encephalopathy, and these must be differentiated from those dementing syndromes caused by other pathologies. Specific tests used in the diagnostic batteries of tests must include a broad sampling of cognitive function tests which will generate predictions about the patient’s functioning and daily life, as well as tests which have been demonstrated previously to be sensitive to the effects of known neurotoxins. These standardized batteries must include tests which have been validated on patients with specific types of brain damage and structural deficits, to clearly separate these conditions from neurotoxic effects. In addition, tests must include internal control measures to detect the influence of motivation, hypochondriasis, depression and learning difficulties, and must contain language that takes into account cultural as well as educational background effects.

A continuum exists from mild to severe central nervous system impairment experienced by patients exposed to toxicant substances:

    • Organic affective syndrome (Type I Effect), in which mild mood disorders predominate as the patient’s chief complaint, with features most consistent with those of organic affective disorders of the depressive type. This syndrome seems to be reversible following cessation of exposure to the offending agent.
    • Mild chronic toxicant encephalopathy, in which, in addition to mood disturbances, central nervous system impairment is more prominent. Patients have evidence of memory and psychomotor function disturbance which can be confirmed by neuropsychological testing. In addition, features of visual spatial impairment and abstract concept formation may be seen. Activities of daily living and work performance are impaired.
    • Sustained personality or mood change (Type IIA Effect) or impairment in intellectual function (Type II) may be seen. In mild chronic toxicant encephalopathy, the course is insidious. Features may persist after the cessation of exposure and disappear gradually, while in some individuals, persistent functional impairment may be observed. If exposure continues, the encephalopathy may progress to a more severe stage.
    • In severe chronic toxicant encephalopathy (Type III Effect) dementia with global deterioration of memory and other cognitive problems are noted. The clinical effects of toxicant encephalopathy are not specific to a given agent. Chronic encephalopathy associated with toluene, lead and arsenic is not different from that of other toxicant aetiologies. The presence of other associated findings, however (visual disturbances with methyl alcohol), may help differentiate syndromes according to particular chemical aetiologies.

           

          Workers exposed to solvents for long periods of time may exhibit disturbances of central nervous system function which are permanent. Since an excess of subjective symptoms, including headache, fatigue, impaired memory, loss of appetite and diffuse chest pains, have been reported, it is often difficult to confirm this effect in any individual case. An epidemiological study comparing house painters exposed to solvents with unexposed industrial workers showed, for example, that painters had significantly lower mean scores on psychological tests measuring intellectual capacity and psychomotor coordination than referent subjects. The painters also had significantly lower performances than expected on memory and reaction time tests. Differences between workers exposed for several years to jet fuel and unexposed workers, in tests demanding close attention and high sensory motor speed, were apparent as well. Impairments in psychological performance and personality changes have also been reported among car painters. These included visual and verbal memory, reduction of emotional reactivity, and poor performance on verbal intelligence tests.

          Most recently, a controversial neurotoxicant syndrome, multiple chemical sensitivity, has been described. Such patients develop a variety of features involving multiple organ systems when they are exposed to even low levels of various chemicals found in the workplace and the environment. Mood disturbances are characterized by depression, fatigue, irritability and poor concentration. These symptoms reoccur on exposure to predictable stimuli, by elicitation by chemicals of diverse structural and toxicological classes, and at levels much lower than those causing adverse responses in the general population. Many of the symptoms of multiple chemical sensitivity are shared by individuals who show only a mild form of mood disturbance, headache, fatigue, irritability and forgetfulness when they are in a building with poor ventilation and with off-gassing of volatile substances from synthetic building materials and carpets. The symptoms disappear when they leave these environments.

          Disturbances of consciousness, seizures and coma

          When the brain is deprived of oxygen—for example, in the presence of carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, methane or agents which block tissue respiration such as hydrocyanic acid, or those which cause massive impregnation of the nerve such as certain organic solvents—disturbances of consciousness may result. Loss of consciousness may be preceded by seizures in workers with exposure to anticholinesterase substances such as organophosphate insecticides. Seizures may also occur with lead encephalopathy associated with brain swelling. Manifestations of acute toxicity following organophosphate poisoning have autonomic nervous system manifestations which precede the occurrence of dizziness, headache, blurred vision, myosis, chest pain, increased bronchial secretions, and seizures. These parasympathetic effects are explained by the inhibitory action of these toxicant substances on cholinesterase activity.

          Movement disorders

          Slowness of movement, increased muscle tone, and postural abnormalities have been observed in workers exposed to manganese, carbon monoxide, carbon disulphide and the toxicity of a meperidine by-product, 1-methyl-4-phenyl-1,2,3,6-tetrahydropyridine (MPTP). At times, the individuals may appear to have Parkinson’s disease. Parkinsonism secondary to toxicant exposure has features of other nervous disorders such as chorea and athetosis. The typical “pill-rolling” tremor is not seen in these instances, and usually the cases do not respond well to the drug levodopa. Dyskinesia (impairment of the power of voluntary motion) can be a common symptom of bromomethane poisoning. Spasmodic movements of the fingers, face, peribuccal muscles and the neck, as well as extremity spasms, may be seen. Tremor is common following mercury poisoning. More obvious tremor associated with ataxia (lack of coordination of muscular action) is noted in individuals following toluene inhalation.

          Opsoclonus is an abnormal eye movement which is jerky in all directions. This is often seen in brain-stem encephalitis, but may also be a feature following chlordecone exposure. The abnormality consists of irregular bursts of abrupt, involuntary, rapid, simultaneous jerking of both eyes in a conjugate manner, possibly multidirectional in severely affected individuals.

          Headache

          Common complaints of head pain following exposure to various metal fumes such as zinc and other solvent vapours may result from vasodilation (widening of the blood vessels), as well as cerebral oedema (swelling). The experiencing of pain is common to these conditions, as well as carbon monoxide, hypoxia (low oxygen), or carbon dioxide conditions. “Sick building syndrome” is thought to cause headaches because of excess carbon dioxide present in a poorly ventilated area.

          Peripheral neuropathy

          Peripheral nerve fibres serving motor functions begin in motor neurons in the ventral horn of the spinal cord. The motor axons extend peripherally to the muscles they innervate. A sensory nerve fibre has its nerve cell body in the dorsal root ganglion or in the dorsal grey matter of the spinal cord. Having received information from the periphery detected at distal receptors, nerve impulses are conducted centrally to the nerve cell bodies where they connect with spinal cord pathways transmitting information to the brain stem and cerebral hemispheres. Some sensory fibres have immediate connections with motor fibres within the spinal cord, providing a basis for reflex activity and quick motor responses to noxious sensations. These sensory-motor relationships exist in all parts of the body; the cranial nerves are the peripheral nerve equivalents arising in brain stem, rather than spinal cord, neurons. Sensory and motor nerve fibres travel together in bundles and are referred to as the peripheral nerves.

          Toxicant effects of peripheral nerve fibres may be divided into those which primarily affect axons (axonopathies), those which are involved in distal sensory-motor loss, and those which primarily affect myelin sheath and Schwann cells. Axonopathies are evident in early stages in the lower extremities where the axons are the longest and farthest from the nerve cell body. Random demyelination occurs in segments between nodes of Ranvier. If sufficient axonal damage occurs, secondary demyelination follows; as long as axons are preserved, regeneration of Schwann cells and remyelination can occur. A pattern seen commonly in toxicant neuropathies is distal axonopathy with secondary segmental demyelination. The loss of myelin reduces the speed of conducting nerve impulses. Thus, gradual onset of intermittent tingling and numbness progressing to lack of sensation and unpleasant sensations, muscle weakness, and atrophy results from damage to the motor and sensory fibres. Reduced or absent tendon reflexes and anatomically consistent patterns of sensory loss, involving the lower extremities more than upper, are features of peripheral neuropathy.

          Motor weaknesses may be noted in distal extremities and progress to unsteady gait and inability to grasp objects. The distal portions of the extremities are involved to a greater extent, but severe cases may produce proximal muscle weakness or atrophy as well. Extensor muscle groups are involved before the flexors. Symptoms may sometimes progress for a few weeks even after removal from exposure. Deterioration of nerve function may persist for several weeks after removal from exposure.

          Depending on the type and severity of neuropathy, an electrophysiological examination of the peripheral nerves is useful to document impaired function. Slowing of conduction velocity, reduced amplitudes of sensory or motor action potentials, or prolonged latencies can be observed. Slowing of motor or sensory conduction velocities is generally associated with demyelination of nerve fibres. Preservation of normal conduction velocity values in the presence of muscle atrophy suggests axonal neuropathy. Exceptions occur when there is progressive loss of motor and sensory nerve fibres in axonal neuropathy which affects the maximal conduction speed as a result of the dropping out of the larger diameter faster conducting nerve fibres. Regenerating fibres occur in early stages of recovery in axonopathies, in which conduction is slowed, especially in the distal segments. The electrophysiological study of patients with toxicant neuropathies should include measurements of motor and sensory conduction velocity in the upper and lower extremities. Special attention should be given to the primarily sensory conducting characteristics of the sural nerve in the leg. This is of great value when the sural nerve is then used for biopsy, providing anatomical correlation between the histology of teased nerve fibres and the conduction characteristics. A differential electrophysiological study of the conducting capabilities of proximal segments versus distal segments of a nerve is useful in identifying a distal toxicant axonopathy, or to localize a neuropathic block of conduction, probably due to demyelination.

          Understanding the pathophysiology of a suspected neurotoxicant polyneuropathy has great value. For example, in patients with neuropathy caused by n-hexane and methylbutyl ketone, motor nerve conduction velocities are reduced, but in some cases, the values may fall within the normal range if only the fastest firing fibres are stimulated and used as the measured outcome. Since neurotoxicant hexacarbon solvents cause axonal degeneration, secondary changes arise in myelin and explain overall reduction in conduction velocity despite the value within the normal range produced by the preserved conducting fibres.

          Electrophysiological techniques include special tests other than the direct conduction velocity, amplitude and latency studies. Somatosensory evoked potentials, auditory evoked potentials, and visual evoked potentials are ways of studying the characteristics of the sensory conducting systems, as well as specific cranial nerves. Afferent-efferent circuitry can be tested by using blink reflex tests involving the 5th cranial nerve to 7th cranial innervated muscle responses; H-reflexes involve segmental motor reflex pathways. Vibration stimulation selects out larger fibres from smaller fibre involvements. Well-controlled electronic techniques are available for measuring the threshold needed to elicit a response, and then to determine the speed of travel of that response, as well as the amplitude of the muscle contraction, or the amplitude and pattern of an evoked sensory action potential. All physiological results must be evaluated in light of the clinical picture and with an understanding of the underlying pathophysiological process.

          Conclusion

          The differentiation of a neurotoxicant syndrome from a primary neurological disease poses a formidable challenge to physicians in the occupational setting. Obtaining a good history, maintaining a high degree of suspicion and adequate follow-up of an individual, as well as groups of individuals, is necessary and rewarding. Early recognition of illness related to toxicant agents in their environment or to a particular occupational exposure is critical, since proper diagnosis can lead to early removal of an individual from the hazards of ongoing exposure to a toxicant substance, preventing possible irreversible neurological damage. Furthermore, recognition of the earliest affected cases in a particular setting may result in changes that will protect others who have not yet become affected.

           

          Back

          Current knowledge of the short- and long-term manifestations of exposure to neurotoxic substances comes from experimental animal studies and human chamber studies, epidemiological studies of active and retired and/or diseased workers, clinical studies and reports, as well as large-scale disasters, such as those that occurred in Bhopal, following a leak of methyl isocyanate, and in Minamata, from methyl mercury poisoning.

          Exposure to neurotoxic substances can produce immediate effects (acute) and/or long-term effects (chronic). In both cases, the effects can be reversible and disappear over time following reduction or cessation of exposure, or result in permanent, irreversible damage. The severity of acute and chronic nervous system impairment depends on exposure dose, which includes both the quantity and duration of exposure. Like alcohol and recreational drugs, many neurotoxic substances may initially be excitatory, producing a sensation of well-being or euphoria and/or speeding up motor functions; as the dose increases in quantity or in time, these same neurotoxins will depress the nervous system. Indeed, narcosis (a state of stupor or insensibility) is induced by a large number of neurotoxic substances, which are mind-altering and depress the central nervous system.

          Acute Poisoning

          Acute effects reflect the immediate response to the chemical substance. The severity of the symptoms and resulting disorders depends on the quantity that reaches the nervous system. With mild exposures, acute effects are mild and transient, disappearing when exposure ceases. Headache, tiredness, light-headedness, difficulty concentrating, feelings of drunkenness, euphoria, irritability, dizziness and slowed reflexes are the types of symptoms experienced during exposure to neurotoxic chemicals. Although these symptoms are reversible, when exposure is repeated day after day, the symptoms recur as well. Moreover, since the neurotoxic substance is not immediately eliminated from the body, symptoms can persist following work. Reported symptoms at a particular workstation are a good reflection of chemical interference with the nervous system and should be considered a warning signal for potential over-exposure; preventive measures to reduce exposure levels should be initiated.

          If exposure is very high, as can occur with spills, leaks, explosions and other accidents, symptoms and signs of intoxication are debilitating (severe headaches, mental confusion, nausea, dizziness, incoordination, blurred vision, loss of consciousness); if exposure is high enough, effects can be long-lasting, possibly resulting in coma and death.

          Acute pesticide-related disorders are a common occurrence among agricultural workers in food-producing countries, where large amounts of toxic substances are used as insecticides, fungicides, nematicides, and herbicides. Organophosphates, carbamates, organochlorines, pyrethrum, pyrethrin, paraquat and diquat are among the major categories of pesticides; however, there are thousands of pesticide formulations, containing hundreds of different active ingredients. Some pesticides, such as maneb, contain manganese, while others are dissolved in organic solvents. In addition to the symptoms mentioned above, acute organophosphate and carbamate poisoning may be accompanied by salivation, incontinence, convulsions, muscle twitching, diarrhoea, visual disturbances, as well as respiratory difficulties and a rapid heart rate; these result from an excess of the neurotransmitter acetylcholine, which occurs when these substances attack a chemical called cholinesterase. Blood cholinesterase decreases proportionally to the degree of acute organophosphate or carbamate intoxication.

          With some substances, such as organophosphorus pesticides and carbon monoxide, high-level acute exposures can produce delayed deterioration of certain parts of the nervous system. For the former, numbness and tingling, weakness and disequilibrium can occur a few weeks after exposure, while for the latter, delayed neurologic deterioration can take place, with symptoms of mental confusion, ataxia, motor incoordination and paresis. Repeated acute episodes of high levels of carbon monoxide have been associated with later-life Parkinsonism. It is possible that high exposures to certain neurotoxic chemicals may be associated with an increased risk for neurodegenerative disorders later on in life.

          Chronic Poisoning

          Recognition of the hazards of neurotoxic chemicals has led many countries to reduce the permissible exposure levels. However, for most chemicals, the level at which no adverse effect will occur over long-term exposure is still unknown. Repeated exposure to low to medium levels of neurotoxic substances throughout many months or years can alter nervous system functions in an insidious and progressive manner. Continued interference with molecular and cellular processes causes neurophysiological and psychological functions to undergo slow alterations, which in the early stages may go unseen since there are large reserves in the nervous system circuitry and damage can, in the first stages, be compensated through new learning.

          Thus, initial nervous system injury is not necessarily accompanied by functional disorders and may be reversible. However, as the damage progresses, symptoms and signs, often non-specific in nature, become apparent, and individuals may seek medical attention. Finally, impairment may become so severe that a clear clinical syndrome, generally irreversible, is manifest.

          Figure 1 schematizes the health deterioration continuum associated with exposure to neurotoxic substances. Progression of neurotoxic dysfunction is dependent on both the duration and concentration of exposure (dose), and may be influenced by other workplace factors, individual health status and susceptibility as well as lifestyle, particularly drinking and exposure to neurotoxic substances used in hobbies, such as glues applied in furniture assembly or plastic model building, paints and paint removers.

          Figure 1. Health deterioration on a continuum with increasing dosage

          NER040F1

          Different strategies are adopted for identification of neurotoxin-related illness among individual workers and for the surveillance of early nervous system deterioration among active workers. Clinical diagnosis relies on a constellation of signs and symptoms, coupled to the medical and exposure history for an individual; aetiologies other than exposure must be systematically ruled out. For the surveillance of early dysfunction among active workers, the group portrait of dysfunction is important. Most often, the pattern of dysfunction observed for the group will be similar to the pattern of impairment clinically observed in the disease. It is somewhat like summing early, mild alterations to produce a picture of what is happening to the nervous system. The pattern or profile of the overall early response provides an indication of the specificity and the type of action of the particular neurotoxic substance or mixture. In workplaces with potential exposure to neurotoxic substances, health surveillance of groups of workers may prove particularly useful for prevention and workplace action in order to avoid the development of more severe illness (see Figure 2). Workplace studies carried out throughout the world, with active workers exposed to specific neurotoxic substances or to mixtures of various chemicals, have provided valuable information on early manifestations of nervous system dysfunction in groups of exposed workers.

          Figure 2. Preventing neurotoxicity at work.

          NER090F1

          Early symptoms of chronic poisoning

          Altered mood states are most often the first symptoms of the initial changes in nervous system functioning. Irritability, euphoria, sudden mood changes, excessive tiredness, feelings of hostility, anxiousness, depression and tension are among the mood states most often associated with neurotoxic exposures. Other symptoms include memory problems, concentration difficulties, headaches, blurred vision, feelings of drunkenness, dizziness, slowness, tingling sensation in hands or feet, loss of libido and so on. Although in the early stages these symptoms are usually not sufficiently severe to interfere with work, they do reflect diminished well-being and affect one’s capacity to fully enjoy family and social relations. Often, because of the non-specific nature of these symptoms, workers, employers and occupational health professionals tend to ignore them and look for causes other than workplace exposure. Indeed, such symptoms may contribute to or aggravate an already difficult personal situation.

          In workplaces where neurotoxic substances are used, workers, employers and occupational health and safety personnel should be particularly aware of the symptomatology of early intoxication, indicative of nervous system vulnerability to exposure. Symptom questionnaires have been developed for worksite studies and surveillance of workplaces where neurotoxic substances are used. Table 1 contains an example of such a questionnaire.

           


          Table 1. Chronic symptoms checklist

           

          Symptoms experienced in the past month

          1.         Have you tired more easily than expected for the type of activity you do?

          2.         Have you felt light-headed or dizzy?

          3.         Have you had difficulty concentrating?

          4.         Have you been confused or disoriented?

          5.         Have you had trouble remembering things?

          6.         Have your relatives noticed that you have trouble remembering things?

          7.         Have you had to make notes to remember things?

          8.         Have you found it hard to understand the meaning of newspapers?

          9.         Have you felt irritable?

          10.       Have you felt depressed?

          11.       Have you had heart palpitations even when you are not exerting yourself?

          12.       Have you had a seizure?

          13.       Have you been sleeping more often than is usual for you?

          14.       Have you had difficulty falling asleep?

          15.       Have you been bothered by incoordination or loss of balance?

          16.       Have you had any loss of muscle strength in your legs or feet?

          17.       Have you had any loss of muscle strength in your arms or hands?

          18.       Have you had difficulty moving your fingers or grasping things?

          19.       Have you had hand numbness and tingling in your fingers lasting for more than a day?

          20.       Have you had hand numbness and tinging in your toes lasting more than a day?

          21.       Have you had headaches at least once a week?

          22.       Have you had difficulty driving home from work because you felt dizzy or tired?

          23.       Have you felt “high” from the chemicals used at work?

          24.       Have you had a lower tolerance for alcohol (takes less to get drunk)?

          Source: Taken from Johnson 1987.


           

          Early motor, sensory and cognitive changes in chronicpoisoning

          With increasing exposure, changes can be observed in motor, sensory and cognitive functions in workers exposed to neurotoxic substances, who do not present clinical evidence of abnormality. Since the nervous system is complex, and certain areas are vulnerable to specific chemicals, while others are sensitive to the action of a large number of toxic agents, a wide range of nervous system functions may be affected by a single toxic agent or a mixture of neurotoxins. Reaction time, hand-eye coordination, short-term memory, visual and auditory memory, attention and vigilance, manual dexterity, vocabulary, switching attention, grip strength, motor speed, hand steadiness, mood, colour vision, vibrotactile perception, hearing and smell are among the many functions that have been shown to be altered by different neurotoxic substances.

          Important information on the type of early deficits that result from exposure has been provided by comparing performance between exposed and non-exposed workers and with respect to the degree of exposure. Anger (1990) provides an excellent review of worksite neurobehavioural research up to 1989. Table 2 adapted from this article, provides an example of the type of neuro-functional deficits that have been consistently observed in groups of active workers exposed to some of the most common neurotoxic substances.

          Table 2. Consistent neuro-functional effects of worksite exposures to some leading neurotoxic substances

           

          Mixed organic solvents

          Carbon disulphide

          Styrene

          Organophos-
          phates

          Lead

          Mercury

          Acquisition

          +

           

           

          +

           

          Affect

          +

           

          +

           

          +

           

          Categorization

          +

           

           

           

           

           

          Coding

          +

          +

           

           

          +

          +

          Colour vision

          +

           

          +

           

           

           

          Concept shifting

          +

           

           

           

           

           

          Distractibility

           

           

           

           

          +

           

          Intelligence

          +

          +

           

          +

          +

          +

          Memory

          +

          +

          +

          +

          +

          +

          Motor coordination

          +

          +

          +

           

          +

          +

          Motor speed

          +

          +

          +

           

          +

          +

          Near visual contrast sensitivity

          +

           

           

           

           

           

          Odour perception threshold

          +

           

           

           

           

           

          Odour identification

          +

           

           

           

          +

           

          Personality

          +

          +

           

           

           

          +

          Spatial relations

          +

          +

           

           

          +

           

          Vibrotactile threshold

          +

           

           

          +

           

          +

          Vigilance

          +

          +

           

           

          +

           

          Visual field

           

           

           

           

          +

          +

          Vocabulary

           

           

           

           

          +

           

          Source: Adapted from Anger 1990.

          Although at this stage in the continuum from well-being to disease, loss is not in the clinically abnormal range, there can be health-related consequences associated with such changes. For example, decreased vigilance and reduced reflexes may put workers in greater danger of accidents. Smell is used to identify leaks and mask saturation (cartridge breakthrough), and acute or chronic loss of smell renders one less apt to identify a potentially hazardous situation. Mood changes may interfere with inter-personal relations at work, socially and in the home. These initial stages of nervous system deterioration, which can be observed by examining groups of exposed workers and comparing them to non-exposed workers or with respect to their degree of exposure, reflect diminished well-being and may be predictive of risk of more serious neurological problems in the future.

          Mental health in chronic poisoning

          Neuropsychiatric disorders have long been attributed to exposure to neurotoxic substances. Clinical descriptions range from affective disorders, including anxiety and depression, to manifestations of psychotic behaviour and hallucinations. Acute high-level exposure to many heavy metals, organic solvents and pesticides can produce delirium. “Manganese madness” has been described in persons with long-term exposure to manganese, and the well-known “mad hatter” syndrome results from mercury intoxication. Type 2a Toxic Encephalopathy, characterized by sustained change in personality involving fatigue, emotional lability, impulse control and general mood and motivation, has been associated with organic solvent exposure. There is growing evidence from clinical and population studies that personality disorders persist over time, long after exposure ceases, although other types of impairment may improve.

          On the continuum from well-being to disease, mood changes, irritability and excessive fatigue are often the very first indications of over-exposure to neurotoxic substances. Although neuropsychiatric symptoms are routinely surveyed in worksite studies, these are rarely presented as a mental health problem with potential consequences on mental and social well-being. For example, changes in mental health status affect one’s behaviour, contributing to difficult inter-personal relationships and disagreements in the home; these in turn can aggravate one’s mental state. In workplaces with employee aid programmes, designed to help employees with personal problems, ignorance of the potential mental health effects of exposure to neurotoxic substances can lead to treatment dealing with the effects rather than the cause. It is interesting to note that among the many reported outbreaks of “mass hysteria” or psychogenic illness, industries with exposure to neurotoxic substances are over-represented. It is possible that these substances, which, for the large part, went unmeasured, contributed to the reported symptoms.

          Mental health manifestations of neurotoxin exposure can be similar to those that are caused by psychosocial stressors associated with poor work organization, as well as psychological reactions to accidents, very stressful occurrences and severe intoxications, called post-traumatic stress disorder (as discussed elsewhere in this Encyclopaedia). A good understanding of the relation between mental health problems and working conditions is important to initiating adequate preventive and curative actions.

          General considerations in assessing early neurotoxicdysfunction

          When evaluating early nervous system dysfunction among active workers, a number of factors must be taken into account. Firstly, many of the neuropsychological and neurophysiological functions that are examined diminish with age; some are influenced by culture or educational level. These factors must be taken into account when considering the relation between exposure and nervous system alterations. This can be done by comparing groups with similar socio-demographic status or by using statistical methods of adjustment. There are, however, certain pitfalls that should be avoided. For example, older workers may have longer work histories, and it has been suggested that some neurotoxic substances may accelerate ageing. Job segregation may confine poorly educated workers, women and minorities in jobs with higher exposures. Secondly, alcohol consumption, smoking and drugs, which all contain neurotoxic substances, may also affect symptoms and performance. A good understanding of the workplace is important in unravelling the different factors that contribute to nervous system dysfunction and the implementation of preventive measures.

           

          Back

          Thursday, 17 February 2011 22:30

          Chemical Neurotoxic Agents

          Definition of Neurotoxicity

          Neurotoxicity refers to the capability of inducing adverse effects in the central nervous system, peripheral nerves or sensory organs. A chemical is considered to be neurotoxic if it is capable of inducing a consistent pattern of neural dysfunction or change in the chemistry or structure of the nervous system.

          Neurotoxicity is generally manifested as a continuum of symptoms and effects, which depend on the nature of the chemical, the dose, the duration of exposure and the traits of the exposed individual. The severity of the observed effects, as well as the evidence for neurotoxicity, increases through levels 1 to 6, shown in Table 1. Short-term or low-dose exposure to a neurotoxic chemical may result in subjective symptoms such as headache and dizziness, but the effect usually is reversible. With increasing dose, neurological changes may show up, and eventually irreversible morphological changes are generated. The degree of abnormality needed for implying neurotoxicity of a chemical agent is a controversial issue. According to the definition, a consistent pattern of neural dysfunction or change in the chemistry or structure of the nervous system is considered if there is well-documented evidence for persistent effects on level 3, 4, 5 or 6 in Table 1. These levels reflect the weight of evidence provided by different signs of neurotoxicity. Neurotoxic substances include naturally occurring elements such as lead, mercury and manganese; biological compounds such as tetrodotoxin (from the puffer fish, a Japanese delicacy) and domoic acid (from contaminated mussels); and synthetic compounds including many pesticides, industrial solvents and monomers.

          Table 1. Grouping neurotoxic effects to reflect their relative strength for establishing neurotoxicity

          Level

          Grouping

          Explanation/Examples

          6

          Morphological changes

          Morphological changes include cell death and axonopathy as well as subcellular morphological changes.

          5

          Neurological changes

          Neurological change embraces abnormal findings in neurological examinations on single individuals.

          4

          Physiological/behavioural changes

          Physiological/behavioural changes comprise experimental findings on groups of animals or humans such as changes in evoked potentials and EEG, or changes in psychological and behavioural tests.

          3

          Biochemical changes

          Biochemical changes cover changes in relevant biochemical parameters (e.g., transmitter level, GFA-protein content (glial fibrillary acidic protein) or enzyme activities).

          21

          Irreversible, subjective symptoms

          Subjective symptoms. No evidence of abnormality on neurological, psychological or other medical examination.

          11

          Reversible, subjective symptoms

          Subjective symptoms. No evidence of abnormality on neurological, psychological, or other medical examination.

          1 Humans only
          Source: Modified from Simonsen et al. 1994.

          In the United States between 50,000 and 100,000 chemicals are in commerce, and 1,000 to 1,600 new chemicals are submitted for evaluation each year. More than 750 chemicals and several classes or groups of chemical compounds are suspected to be neurotoxic (O’Donoghue 1985), but the majority of chemicals have never been tested for neurotoxic properties. Most of the known neurotoxic chemicals available today have been identified by case-reports or through accidents.

          Although neurotoxic chemicals often are produced to fulfil specific uses, exposure may arise from several sources—use in private homes, in agriculture and in industries, or from polluted drinking water and so on. Fixed a priori preconceptions about which neurotoxic compounds are expected to be found in which occupations should therefore be viewed with caution, and the following citations should be looked upon as possible examples including a few of the most common neurotoxic chemicals (Arlien-Søborg 1992; O’Donoghue 1985; Spencer and Schaumburg 1980; WHO 1978).

          Symptoms of Neurotoxicity

          The nervous system generally reacts rather stereotypically to exposure to neurotoxic substances Figure 1. Some typical syndromes are indicated below.

          Figure 1. Neurological and behavioural effects of exposure to neurotoxic chemicals.

          NER030T2

          Polyneuropathy

          This is caused by impairment of motor and sensory nerve function leading to weakness of the muscles, with paresis usually most pronounced peripherally in the upper and lower extremities (hands and feet). Prior or simultaneous paraesthesia (tingling or numbness in the fingers and toes) may occur. This may lead to difficulties in walking or in the fine coordination of hands and fingers. Heavy metals, solvents and pesticides, among other chemicals, may result in such disability, even if the toxic mechanism of these compounds may be totally different.

          Encephalopathy

          This is caused by a diffuse impairment of the brain, and may result in fatigue; impairment of learning, memory and ability to concentrate; anxiety, depression, increased irritability and emotional instability. Such symptoms may indicate early diffuse degenerative brain disorder as well as occupational chronic toxic encephalopathy. Often increased frequency of headaches, dizziness, changes in sleep pattern and reduced sexual activity may also be present from the early stages of the disease. Such symptoms may develop following long-term, low-level exposure to several different chemicals such as solvents, heavy metals or hydrogen sulphide, and are also seen in several dementing disorders not related to work. In some cases more specific neurological symptoms can be seen (e.g., Parkinsonism with tremor, rigidity of the muscles and slowing of movements, or cerebellar symptoms such as tremor and reduced coordination of hand movements and gait). Such clinical pictures can be seen following exposure to some specific chemicals such as manganese, or MPTP (1-methyl-4-phenyl-1,2,3,6-tetrahydropyridine) in the former condition, and toluene or mercury in the latter.

          Gases

          A wide variety of chemicals with totally different chemical structures are gases at normal temperature and have been proven neurotoxic Table 3. Some of them are extremely toxic even in very small doses, and have even been used as war gases (phosgene and cyanide); others require high doses over longer periods to give symptoms (e.g., carbon dioxide). Some are used for general anaesthesia (e.g., nitrous oxide); others are widely used in industry and in agents used for disinfection (e.g., formaldehyde). The former may induce irreversible changes in the nervous system after repeated low-level exposure, the latter apparently produce only acute symptoms. Exposure in small rooms with poor ventilation is particularly hazardous. Some of the gases are odourless, which makes them particularly dangerous (e.g., carbon monoxide). As shown in Table 2, some gases are important constituents in industrial production, while others are the result of incomplete or complete combustion (e.g., CO and CO2 respectively). This is seen in mining, steel works, power stations and so on, but may also be seen in private homes with insufficient ventilation. Essential for treatment is to stop further exposure and provide fresh air or oxygen, and in severe cases artificial ventilation.

          Table 2. Gases associated with neurotoxic effects

          Chemical

          Examples of source of exposure

          Selected industries at risk

          Effects1

          Carbon dioxide (CO2 )

          Welding; fermentation; manufacture, storage and use of dry ice

          Metal industry; mining; breweries

          M: Dilate vessels

          A: Headache; dyspnoea; tremor; loss of consciousness

          C: Hardly any

          Carbon monoxide (CO)

          Car repair; welding; metal melting; drivers; firemen

          Metal industry; mining; transportation; power station

          M: Deprivation of oxygen

          A: Headache; drowsiness; loss of consciousness

          Hydrogen sulphide (H2S)

          Fumigating of green house; manure; fishermen; fish unloading; sewerage handling

          Agriculture; fishing; sewer work

          M: Blocking oxidative metabolism

          A: Loss of consciousness

          C: Encephalopathy

          Cyanide (HCN)

          Electro-welding; galvanic surface treatment with nickel; copper and silver; fumigation of ships, houses foods and soil in green houses

          Metal industry; chemical industry; nursery; mining; gasworks

          M: Blocking of respiratory enzymes

          A: Dyspnoea; falling blood pressure; convulsions; loss of consciousness; death

          C: Encephalopathy; ataxia; neuropathy (e.g., aftereating cavasava)

          Occupational impairment uncertain

          Nitrous oxide (N2O)

          General anaesthesia during operation; light narcosis at dental care and delivery

          Hospitals (anaesthesia); dentists; midwife

          M: Acute change in nerve cell membrane; degeneration of nerve cells after long-term exposure

          A: Light-headedness; drowsiness; loss of consciousness

          C: Numbness of fingers and toes; reduced coordination; encephalopathy

          1 M: mechanism; A: acute effects; C: chronic effects.
          Neuropathy: dysfunction of motor- and sensory peripheral nerve fibres.
          Encephalopathy: brain dysfunction due to generalized impairment of the brain.
          Ataxia: impaired motor coordination.

           

          Metals

          As a rule the toxicity of metals increases with increasing atomic weight, lead and mercury being particularly toxic. Metals are usually found in nature at low concentrations, but in certain industries they are used in great amounts (see Table 3) and may give rise to occupational risk for the workers. Moreover, considerable amounts of metals are found in waste water and may give rise to environmental risk for the residents close to the plants but also at greater distances. Often the metals (or, for example, organic mercury compounds) are taken up into the food chain and will accumulate in fish, birds and animals, representing a risk for consumers. The toxicity and the way in which the metals are handled by the organism may depend on the chemical structure. Pure metals may be taken up by inhalation or skin contact of vapour (mercury) and/or small particles (lead), or orally (lead). Inorganic mercury compounds (e.g., HgCl2) are mainly taken up by mouth, while organic metal compounds (e.g., tetraethyl lead) mainly are taken up by inhalation or by skin contact. The body burden may to a certain degree be reflected in the concentration of metal in the blood or urine. This is the basis for biological monitoring. In treatment it must be recalled that especially lead is released very slowly from deposits in the body. The amount of lead in bones will normally be reduced by only 50% over 10 years. This release may be speeded up by the use of chelating agents: BAL (dimercapto-1-propanol), Ca-EDTA or penicillamine.

          Table 3. Metals and their inorganic compounds associated with neurotoxicity

          Chemical

          Examples of source of exposure

          Selected industries at risk

          Effects1

          Lead

          Melting; soldering; grinding; repair; glazing; plasticizer

          Metal work; mining; accumulator plants; car repair; shipyards; glass workers; ceramics; pottery; plastic

          M: Impairment of oxidative metabolism of nerve cells and glia

          A: Abdominal pain; headache; encephalopathy; seizures

          C: Encephalopathy; polyneuropathy, including drop hand

          Mercury Elemental

          Electrolysis; electrical instruments (gyroscope; manometer; thermometer; battery; electric bulb; tubes, etc.); amalgam filling

          Chloralkali plants; mining; electronics; dentistry; polymer production; paper and pulp industry

          M: Impairment at multiple sites in nerve cells

          A: Lung inflammation; headache; impaired speech

          C: Inflammation of gums; appetite loss; encephalopathy; including tremor; irritability

          Calomel Hg2Cl2

           

          Laboratories

          A: Low acute toxicity chronic toxic effects, see above

          Sublimate HgCl2

          Disinfection

          Hospitals; clinics; laboratories

          M: Acute tubular and glomerular renal degeneration. Verytoxic even in small oral doses, lethal down to 30 mg/kgweight

          C: See above.

          Manganese

          Melting (steel alloy); cutting; welding in steel; dry batteries

          Manganese mining; steel and aluminium production; metal industry; battery production; chemical industry; brickyard

          M: Not known, possible changes in dopamine and catecholamine in basal ganglia in the centre of the brain

          A: Dysphoria

          C: Encephalopathy including Parkinsonism; psychosis; appetite loss; irritability; headache; weakness

          Aluminium

          Metallurgy; grinding; polishing

          Metal industry

          M: Unknown

          C: Possibly encephalopathy

          1 M: mechanism; A: acute effects; C: chronic effects.
          Neuropathy: dysfunction of motor- and sensory peripheral nerve fibres.
          Encephalopathy: brain dysfunction due to generalized impairment of the brain.

           

          Monomers

          Monomers constitute a large, heterogeneous group of reactive chemicals used for chemical synthesis and production of polymers, resins and plastics. Monomers comprise polyhalogenated aromatic compounds such as p-chlorobenzene and 1,2,4-trichlorbenzene; unsaturated organic solvents such as styrene and vinyltoluene, acrylamide and related compounds, phenols, ɛ-caprolactam and ζ-aminobutyrolactam. Some of the widely used neurotoxic monomers and their effect on the nervous system are listed in Table 3. Occupational exposure to neurotoxic monomers may take place at industries manufacturing, transporting and using chemical products and plastic products. During handling of polymers containing rest monomers, and during moulding in boat yards and in dental clinics, a substantial exposure to neurotoxic monomers takes place. Upon exposure to these monomers uptake may take place during inhalation (e.g., carbon disulphide and styrene) or by skin contact (e.g., acrylamide). As monomers are a heterogeneous group of chemicals, several different mechanisms of toxicity are likely. This is reflected by differences in symptoms (Table 4).

          Table 4. Neurotoxic monomers

          Compound

          Examples of source of exposure

          Selected industries at risk

          Effects1

          Acrylamide

          Employees exposed to the monomer

          Polymer production; tunnelling and drilling operations

          M: Impaired axonal transport

          C: Polyneuropathy; dizziness; tremor and ataxia

          Acrylonitrile

          Accidents in labs and industries; house fumigation

          Polymer and rubber production; chemical synthesis

          A: Hyperexcitability; salivation; vomiting; cyanosis; ataxia; difficulty breathing

          Carbon disulphide

          Production of rubber and viscose rayon

          Rubber and viscose rayon industries

          M: Impaired axonal transport and enzyme activity is likely

          C: Peripheral neuropathy; encephalopathy; headache; vertigo; gastrointestinal disturbances

          Styrene

          Production of glass-reinforced plastics; monomer manufacture and transportation; use of styrene-containing resins and coatings

          Chemical industry; fibreglass production; polymer industry

          M: Unknown

          A: Central nervous system depression; headache

          C: Polyneuropathy; encephalopathy; hearing loss

          Vinyltoluene

          Resin production; insecticide compounds

          Chemical and polymer industry

          C: Polyneuropathy; reduced motor nerve conductionvelocity

          1 M: mechanism; A: acute effects; C: chronic effects.
          Neuropathy: dysfunction of motor and sensory peripheral nerve fibres.
          Encephalopathy: brain dysfunction due to generalized impairment of the brain.
          Ataxia: impaired motor coordination.

           

          Organic solvents

          Organic solvents is a common designation for a large group of more than 200 lipophilic chemical compounds capable of dissolving fats, oils, waxes, resins, rubber, asphalt, cellulose filaments and plastic materials. They are usually fluids at room temperature with boiling points below 200 to 250°C, and are easily evaporated. They are mainly taken up via the lungs but some may penetrate the skin as well. Due to their lipophilicity they are distributed to organs rich in fat. Thus high concentrations are found in body fat, bone marrow, liver and brain, which also may act as reservoirs of solvents. The partition coefficient octanol/water can indicate whether high brain concentrations are to be expected. The mechanism of toxicity is not yet known, but several possibilities have been envisioned: blocking important enzymes in the metabolic breakdown of glucose and thus reducing energy available for neuronal processing; reducing energy formation in the mitochondria; changing neuronal membranes, leading to impairment of ion channel function; slowing of axonal flow. Methylene chloride is metabolized to CO, which blocks the transport of oxygen in the blood. Large groups of workers in a great variety of professions are exposed daily or at least frequently (see Table 5). In some countries the consumption of organic solvents has declined in some occupations due to hygienic improvements and substitution (e.g., house painters, graphic industry workers, metal workers), while in other occupations the pattern of exposure has changed but the total amount of organic solvents has remained unchanged. For example, trichloroethylene has been replaced by 1,1,1-trichloroethane and freon. So solvents are still a major hygienic problem at many workplaces. People are at particular risk when exposed in small rooms with poor ventilation and with high temperature, increasing the evaporation. Physical work increases the pulmonary uptake of solvents. In several countries (in particular the Nordic countries), compensation has been given to workers who have developed chronic toxic encephalopathy following long-term, low-level exposure to solvents.

          Table 5. Organic solvents associated with neurotoxicity

          Chemical

          Examples of source of exposure

          Selected industries at risk

          Effects1

          Chlorinated hydrocarbons: trichloroethylene;

          1,1,1-trichloroethane; tetrachloroethylene

          Degreasing; electroplating; painting; printing; cleaning; general and light anaesthesia

          Metal industry; graphic industry; electronic industry; dry cleaners; anaesthetists

          M: Unknown

          A: Prenarcotic symptoms

          C: Encephalopathy; polyneuropathy; trigeminal affection (TRI); hearing loss

          Methylene chloride

          Extraction, including extraction of caffeine; paint remover

          Food industry; painters; graphic industry

          M: Metabolism ® CO

          A: Prenarcotic symptoms; coma

          C: Encephalopathy

          Methyl chloride

          Refrigerator production and repair

          Refrigerator production; rubber industry; plastic industry

          M: Unknown

          A: Prenarcotic symptoms; loss of consciousness; death

          C: Encephalopathy

          Toluene

          Printing; cleaning; degreasing; electroplating; painting; spray painting

          Graphic industry; electronic industry

          M: Unknown

          A: Prenarcotic symptoms

          C: Encephalopathy; cerebellar dysfunction; polyneuropathy; hearing loss; visual disturbance

          Xylene

          Printing; synthesis of phthalic anhydride; painting; histology laboratory procedures

          Graphic industry; plastic industry; histology laboratories

          M: Unknown

          A: Prenarcotic symptoms

          C: Encephalopathy; visual disturbance; hearing loss

          Styrene

          Polymerization; moulding

          Plastic industry; fibreglass production

          M: Unknown

          A: Prenarcotic symptoms

          C: Encephalopathy; polyneuropathy; hearing loss

          Hexacarbons: n-hexane;

          methyl butyl ketone (MBK);

          methyl ethyl ketone (MEK)

          Gluing; printing; plastic coating; painting; extraction

          Leather and shoe industry; graphic industry; painter; laboratories

          M: Impairment of axonal transport

          A: Prenarcotic

          C: Polyneuropathy; encephalopathy

          Various solvents: Freon 113

          Refrigerator production and repair; dry cleaning; degreasing

          Refrigerator production; metal industry; electronic industry; dry cleaning

          M: Unknown

          A: Mild prenarcotic symptoms

          C: Encephalopathy

          Diethylether; halothane

          General anaesthetics (nurses; doctors)

          Hospitals; clinics

          M: Unknown

          A: Prenarcotic symptoms

          C: Encephalopathy

          Carbon disulphide

          See monomers

          See monomers

          See monomers

          Mixtures: white spirit and thinner

          Painting; degreasing; cleaning; printing; impregnation; surface treatment

          Metal industry; graphic industry; wood industry; painters

          M: Unknown

          A: Prenarcotic symptoms

          C: Encephalopathy

           1 M: mechanism; A: acute effects; C: chronic effects.

          Neuropathy: dysfunction of motor- and sensory peripheral nerve fibres.
          Encephalopathy: brain dysfunction due to generalized impairment of the brain

           

          Pesticides

          Pesticides is used as a generic term for any chemical designed to kill groups of plants or animals that are a human health hazard or may cause economic loss. It includes insecticides, fungicides, rodenticides, fumigants and herbicides. Approximately 5 billion pounds of pesticide products made up of more than 600 active pesticide ingredients are annually used in agriculture worldwide. Organophosphorus, carbamate and organochlorine pesticides together with pyrethroids, chlorophenoxy herbicides and organic metal compounds used as fungicides have neurotoxic properties (Table 6). Among the many different chemicals used as rodenticides, some (e.g., strychnine, zinc phosphide and thallium) are neurotoxic too. Occupational exposure to neurotoxic pesticides is mainly associated with agricultural work such as pesticide handling and working with treated crops, but exterminators, pesticide manufacturing and formulating employees, highway and railway workers, as well as greenhouse, forestry and nursery workers may have a substantial risk of being exposed to neurotoxic pesticides as well. Children, who constitute a significant proportion of the agricultural workforce, are especially vulnerable because their nervous systems are not fully developed. The acute effects of pesticides are generally well described, and long-lasting effects upon repeated exposure or single high dose exposure are often seen (Table 6), but the effect of repeated subclinical exposure is uncertain.

          Table 6. Classes of common neurotoxic pesticides, exposure, effects and associated symptoms

          Compound

          Examples of source of exposure

          Selected industries at risk

          Effects1

          Organo-phosphorus compounds: Beomyl; Demethon; Dichlorvos; Ethyl parathion; Mevinphos; Phosfolan; Terbufos; Malathion

          Handling; treatment of crops; working with treated crops; dock labourer

          Agriculture; forestry; chemical; gardening

          M: Acetyl cholinesterase inhibition

          A: Hyperactivity; neuromuscular paralysis; visual impairment; breathing difficulty; restlessness; weakness; vomiting; convulsions

          Carbamates: Aldicarb; Carbaryl; Carbofuran; Propoxur

             

          M: Delayed neurotoxicity axonopathy2

          C: Polyneuropathy; numbness and tingling in feet; muscle weakness; sensory disturbance; paralysis

          Organochlorine: Aldrin; Dieldrin; DDT; Endrin; Heptachlor; Lindane; Methoxychlor; Mirex; Toxaphene

          See above

          See above

          A: Excitability; apprehension; dizziness; headache; confusion; loss of balance; weakness; ataxia; tremors; convulsions; coma

          C: Encephalopathy

          Pyrethroids

          See above

          See above

          M: Altering flow of sodium ions through nerve cellmembrane

          A: Repeated firing of the nerve cell; tremor; convulsion

          2,4-D

          Herbicide

          Agriculture

          C: Polyneuropathy

          Triethyltin hydroxide

          Surface treatment; handling treated wood

          Wood and wood products

          A: Headache; weakness; paralysis; visual disturbances

          C: Polyneuropathy; CNS effects

          Methyl bromide

          Fumigating

          Greenhouses; insecticide; manufacture of refrigerators

          M: Unknown

          A: Visual and speech disturbances; delirium; convulsion

          C: Encephalopathy

          1 M: mechanism; A: acute effects; C: chronic effects.
          Neuropathy: dysfunction of motor and sensory peripheral nerve fibres.
          Encephalopathy: brain dysfunction due to generalized impairment of the brain.
          Ataxia: impaired motor coordination.
          2 Mainly phosphates or phosphonates.

           

          Other chemicals

          Several different chemicals which do not fit into the above-mentioned groups also possess neurotoxicity. Some of these are used as pesticides but also in different industrial processes. Some have well-documented acute and chronic neurotoxic effects; others have obvious acute effects, but the chronic effects are only poorly examined. Examples of these chemicals, their uses and effects are listed in Table 7.

          Table 7. Other chemicals associated with neurotoxicity

          Chemical

          Examples of source of exposure

          Selected industries at risk

          Effects1

          Boric acid

          Welding; fluxes; preservation

          Metal; glass

          A: Delirium; convulsion

          C: CNS depression.

          Disulfiram

          Pharmaceutical

          Rubber

          C: Fatigue; peripheral neuropathy; sleepiness

          Hexachlorophene

          Antibacterial soaps

          Chemical

          C: CNS oedema; peripheral nerve damage

          Hydrazine

          Reducing agents

          Chemical; army

          A: Excitement; appetite loss; tremor; convulsion

          Phenol/Cresol

          Antiseptics

          Plastics; resins; chemical; hospitals; laboratories

          M: Denatures proteins and enzymes

          A: Reflex loss; weakness; tremor; sweating; coma

          C: Appetite loss; mental disturbance; ringing in the ears

          Pyridine

          Ethanol denaturation

          Chemical; textile

          A: CNS depression; mental depression; fatigue; appetite loss

          C: Irritability; sleep disorders; polyneuropathy; double vision

          Tetraethyl lead

          Gasoline additive

          Chemical; transport

          C: Irritability; weakness; tremor; vision difficulties

          Arsine

          Batteries; insecticide; melting

          Smelting; glasswork; ceramics;  manufacture of paper

          M: Impairing enzyme function

          A: Reduced sensation; paresis; convulsion; coma

          C: Motor impairment; ataxia; vibration sense loss; polyneuropathy

          Lithium

          Oil additive; pharmaceutical

          Petrochemical

          A/C: Appetite loss; ringing in the ears; vision blurring; tremor; ataxia

          Selenium

          Melting; production of rectifiers; vulcanization; cutting oils; antioxidant

          Electronic; glass works; metal industry; rubber industry

          A: Delirium; anosmia

          C: Odour of garlic; polyneuropathy; nervousness

          Thallium

          Rodenticide

          Glass; glass products

          A: Appetite loss; tiredness; drowsiness; metallic taste; numbness; ataxia

          Tellurium

          Melting; rubber production; catalyst

          Metal; chemical; rubber; electronic

          A: Headache; drowsiness; neuropathy

          C: Odour of garlic; metallic taste; Parkinsonism; depression

          Vanadium

          Melting

          Mining; steel production; chemical industry

          A: Appetite loss; ringing in the ears; somnolence, tremor

          C: Depression; tremor; blindness

          1 M: mechanism; A: acute effects; C: chronic effects.
          Neuropathy: dysfunction of motor and sensory peripheral nerve fibres.
          Encephalopathy: brain dysfunction due to generalized impairment of the brain.
          Ataxia: impaired motor coordination

           

          Back

          Thursday, 17 February 2011 21:59

          Anatomy and Physiology

          Nerve cells are the functional units of the nervous system. The nervous system is believed to have ten thousand million of such cells, called neurons and glia, the glia being present in greater numbers than neurons.

          The Neuron

          Figure 1 is an idealized diagram of a neuron with its three most important structural features: the cell body, the dendrites and the axon terminal.

          Figure 1. The anatomy of the neuron

          NER020F1

          The dendrites are finely branched processes arising near the cell body of a neuron. The dendrites receive excitatory or inhibitory effects via chemical messengers called neurotransmitters. The cytoplasm is the material of the cell body in which the organelles—including the cell nucleus—and other inclusions are found Figure 2. The nucleus contains the cell’s chromatin, or genetic material.

           

           

           

           

           

           

           

           

           

           

          Figure 2. The organelles

          NER020F2

          The nucleus of the nerve cell is atypical compared with that of other living cells in that, although it contains the genetic material deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA), the DNA is not involved in the process of cell division; that is, after reaching maturity, nerve cells do not divide. (An exception to this rule are the neurons in the nose lining (olfactory epithelium).) The nucleus is rich in ribonucleic acid (RNA), which is necessary for the synthesis of protein. Three types of proteins have been identified: cytosolic proteins, which form the fibrillar elements of the nerve cell; intracondrial proteins, which generate energy for cell activity; and proteins that form membranes and secretory products. Neurons are now conceived of as modified secretory cells. Secretory granules are formed, stored in synaptic vesicles and later released as neurotransmitter substances, the chemical messengers between nerve cells.

          The fibrillar elements, which form the skeleton of the neuron, participate in the trophic function of the neuron, acting as vehicles of transmission. Axonal transport can be anterograde (cell body to axon terminal) and retrograde (axon terminal to cell body). From the thickest to the thinnest, three types of fibrillar elements are recognized: microtubules, neurofilaments and microfilaments.

          Glial Cells

          In contrast to neurons, glial cells do not, by themselves, carry electrical messages. There are two types of glial cells: the macroglia and the microglia. The macroglia is a name given to at least three types of cells: astrocytes, oligodendrocytes and ependymal cells. Microglial cells are primarily scavenger cells for removing debris after neural damage or infection has occurred.

          The glial cells also have distinctive microscopic and ultramicroscopic features. Glial cells physically support neurons, but a number of physiological properties are also now beginning to be understood. Among the most important neuron-glial interactions are the glial cell’s role in providing the neurons with nutrients, removing fragments of neurons after their death and, most importantly, contributing to the process of chemical communication. Glial cells, in sharp contrast to neurons, can divide and thus can reproduce themselves. Tumours of the nervous system, for example, result from an abnormal reproduction of glial cells.

          Myelin

          What appears in the macroscopic observation of neural tissue as “grey matter” and “white matter” has a microscopic and biochemical basis. Microscopically, the grey matter contains the neuronal cell bodies, whereas the white matter is where neural fibres or axons are found. The “white” appearance is due to a sheath—composed of a fatty substance called myelin—covering these fibres. Myelin of the peripheral nerves originates from the membrane of the Schwann cell which wraps around the axon. The myelin of fibres in the central nervous system is provided by the membranes of the oligodendrocytes (a variety of glial cells). Oligodendrocytes usually myelinate several axons, whereas the Schwann cell is associated with only one axon. A discontinuity of the myelin sheath—designated as nodes of Ranvier—exists between continuous Schwann cells or oligodendrocytes. It is estimated that in the longest central motor pathway, up to 2,000 Schwann cells form the myelin cover. Myelin, whose role is to facilitate the propagation of the action potential, may be a specific target of neurotoxic agents. A morphological classification of neurotoxic substances describes characteristic neuropathological changes of the myelin as myelinopathies.

          Trophic Function of the Neuron

          The normal functions of the neuron include protein synthesis, axonal transport, generation and conduction of the action potential, synaptic transmission, and formation and maintenance of the myelin. Some of the basic trophic functions of the neuron were described as early as the 19th century by sectioning the axons (axotomy). Among the processes uncovered, one of the most important was the Wallerian degeneration—after Waller, the English physiologist who described it.

          Wallerian degeneration provides a good opportunity to describe well-known changes in organelles as a result of either traumatic or toxic damage. Parenthetically, the terms used to describe Wallerian degeneration produced by traumatic axotomy are the same ones used to describe changes resulting from neurotoxic agents. At the cellular level, neuropathological changes resulting from toxic damage to neural tissue are far more complex than those occurring as a result of traumatic damage. It is only recently that changes in neurons affected by neurotoxic agents have been observed.

          Twenty-four hours after cutting of the axon, the most distinctive feature is swelling of both sides of the mechanical trauma. Swelling results from accumulation of fluids and membranous elements on both sides of the site of injury. These changes are not unlike those observed in a rain-flooded two-way road with vehicles stopped on both sides of the flooded area. In this analogy, stalled vehicles are the swelling. After a few days, regeneration of the ensheathed axons—i.e., those covered with myelin—occurs. Sprouts grow from the proximal stump moving at the rate of 1 to 3 mm per day. Under favourable conditions, sprouts reach the distal (farther from the cell body) stump. When renervation—joining of the stumps—is completed, the basic features of normal transmission have been re-established. The cell body of the injured neuron undergoes profound structural changes in protein synthesis and axonal transport.

          If molecular neurobiology is said to be a young discipline, the neurobiology of the neurotoxic processes is even younger, and still in its infancy. True, the molecular basis of action of many neurotoxins and pharmacological agents is now well understood. But with some notable exceptions (e.g., lead, methyl mercury, acrylamide) the molecular basis of toxicity of the vast majority of environmental and neurotoxic agents is unknown. That is why, instead of describing the molecular neurobiology of a select group of occupational and environmental neurotoxic agents, we still are forced to refer to the comparatively abundant strategies and examples from classical neuropharmacology or from work in modern drug manufacture.

          Neurotransmitters

          A neurotransmitter is a chemical substance which, when released from axon terminals by the action potential, produces the momentary change in electrical potential when another nerve fibre is stimulated. Neurotransmitters stimulate or inhibit adjacent neurons or effector organs such as muscle and glands. Known neurotransmitters and their neural pathways are now being intensively studied, and new ones are constantly being discovered. Some neurological and psychiatric disorders are now understood to be caused by chemical changes in neurotransmission—for example, myasthenia gravis, Parkinson’s disease, certain forms of affective disorders such as depression, severe distortion of thought processes such as in schizophrenia, and Alzheimer’s disease. Although excellent isolated reports on the effect of several environmental and occupational neurotoxic agents on neurotransmission have been published, the body of knowledge is meagre compared with that existing for neuropsychiatric diseases. Pharmacological studies of manufactured drugs require an understanding of how drugs affect neurotransmission. Drug manufacture and neurotransmission research are thus intimately related. The changing views of drug action have been summarized by Feldman and Quenzer (1984).

          The effects of neurotoxic agents on neurotransmission are characterized by where in the nervous system they act, their chemical receptors, the time course of their effects, whether neurotoxic agents facilitate, block or inhibit neurotransmission, or whether neurotoxic agents alter the termination or removal of the neurotransmitter’s pharmacological action.

          One difficulty experienced by neuroscientists is the need to link known processes that occur at the molecular level in the neuron with events at the cellular level, which in turn may explain how normal and pathological neuropsychological changes occur, as clearly stated in the following which to a large extent still applies: “(A)t the molecular level, an explanation of the action of a drug is often possible; at the cellular level, an explanation is sometimes possible, but at a behavioural level, our ignorance is abysmal” (Cooper, Bloom and Roth 1986).

          The Main Components of the Nervous System

          Knowledge of the main components of the nervous system is essential for the understanding of the gross neuropsychological manifestations of neurotoxic illness, the rationale for the use of specific techniques for the assessment of nervous system functions, and the understanding of pharmacological mechanisms of neurotoxic action. From a functional standpoint, the nervous system can be divided into two major compartments: The somatic nervous system conveys sensory information (touch, temperature, pain and limb position—even when the eyes are closed) from the body segments and carries the neural pathways that innervate and control the movement of skeletal muscles, such as those of the arms, fingers, legs and toes. The visceral nervous system controls internal organs that are not normally under the influence of blood vessels, the dilation and constriction of the pupils of the eyes and so on.

          From an anatomical viewpoint, four main components need to be identified: the central nervous system, the peripheral nervous system including cranial nerves, the autonomic system and the neuroendocrine system.

          The Central Nervous System

          The central nervous system contains the brain and the spinal cord Figure 3. The brain lies in the skull cavity and is protected by the meninges. It is divided into three major components; in ascending order—that is, from the caudal (tail) to cervical (head) portion of the nervous system—they are the hindbrain (also called, the rhombencephalon), the midbrain (the mescencephalon) and the forebrain (the proscencephalon).

          Figure 3. The central and peripheral divisions of the nervous system

          NER020F5

          The hindbrain

          The three major components of the hindbrain are the medulla oblongata, the pons and the cerebellum figure 4.

          Figure 4. The brain shown from a lateral side.

          NER020F7

          The medulla oblongata contains neural structures that control heart rate and breathing, sometimes the targets of neurotoxic agents and drugs causing death. Located between the medulla oblongata and the midbrain, the pons (bridge) derives its names from the large number of fibres traversing its anterior aspect en route to the cerebellar hemispheres. The cerebellum—in Latin, little brain—is characteristically corrugated in appearance. The cerebellum receives sensory information and sends motor messages essential for motor coordination. It is responsible (among other functions) for the execution of fine movements. This scheduling—or programming—requires the adequate timing of sensory inputs and motor responses. The cerebellum is often the target of numerous neurotoxic agents—for example, alcoholic beverages, many industrial solvents, lead—which affect motor responses.

          The midbrain

          The midbrain is a narrow part of the brain connecting the hindbrain to the forebrain. Structures of the midbrain are the cerebral aqueduct, the tectum, the cerebral peduncles, the substantia nigra and the red nucleus. The cerebral aqueduct is a channel that connects the third with the fourth ventricles (liquid-filled cavities of the brain); the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) flows through this opening.

          The forebrain

          This part of the brain is subdivided into diencephalon (“between brain”) and the cerebrum. The major regions of the diencephalon are the thalamus and the hypothalamus. “Thalamus” means “inner room”. The thalami are made up of neuronal groupings, called nuclei, which have five main functions:

          • receiving sensory information and sending it to primary areas of the cerebral cortex
          • sending information about ongoing movement to motor areas of the cerebral cortex
          • sending information on the activity of the limbic system to areas of the cerebral cortex related to this system
          • sending information on intrathalamic activity to association areas of the cerebral cortex
          • sending information of brain-stem reticular formation activity to widespread areas of the cerebral cortex.

           

          The name hypothalamus means “under the thalamus”. It forms the base of the third ventricle, an important reference point for the imaging of the brain. The hypothalamus is a complex, minute neural structure responsible for many aspects of behaviour such as basic biological drives, motivation and emotion. It is the link between the nervous and the neuroendocrine system, to be reviewed below. The pituitary gland (also called the hypophysis) is linked by neurons to the hypothalamic nuclei. It is well established that the hypothalamic nerve cells perform many neurosecretory functions. The hypothalamus is linked with many other major regions of the brain including the rhinencephalon—the primitive cortex originally associated with olfaction—and the limbic system, including the hippocampus.

          The cerebral cortex is the largest component of the brain, consisting of two cerebral hemispheres connected by a mass of white matter called the corpus callosum. The cerebral cortex is the surface layer of each cerebral hemisphere. Deep sulci in the cerebral cortex—the central and the lateral sulci Figure 4 —are taken as reference points to separate anatomical regions of the brain. The frontal lobe lies in front of the central sulcus. The parietal lobe begins at the back of the central sulcus, and lies next to the occipital lobe, which occupies the posterior portion of the brain. The temporal lobe begins well inside the folding of the lateral sulcus and extends into the ventral aspects of the brain hemispheres. Two important components of the cerebrum are the basal ganglia and the limbic system.

          The basal ganglia are nuclei—that is, clusters of nerve cells—located toward the centre of the brain. The basal ganglia comprise major centres of the extra-pyramidal motor system. (The pyramidal system, to which the term is contrasted, is involved in the voluntary control of movement.) The extrapyramidal system is selectively affected by many neurotoxic agents (e.g., manganese). In the past two decades, important discoveries have been made concerning the role these nuclei play in several neural degenerative diseases (e.g., Parkinson’s disease, Huntington’s chorea).

          The limbic system is comprised of convoluted neural structures branching out into many directions and establishing connections with many “old” regions of the brain, particularly with the hypothalamus. It is involved in the control of emotional expression. The hippocampus is believed to be a structure where many memory processes occur.

          The spinal cord

          The spinal cord is a whitish structure situated within the vertebral canal. It is divided into four regions: cervical, thoracic, lumbar and sacral-coccyxeal. The two most easily recognizable features of the spinal cord are the grey matter containing the cell bodies of the neurons, and the white matter containing the myelinated axons of the neurons. The ventral region of the spinal cord’s grey matter contains nerve cells that regulate motor function; the middle region of the thoracic spinal cord is associated with autonomic functions. The dorsal portion receives sensory information from the spinal nerves.

          The Peripheral Nervous System

          The peripheral nervous system includes those neurons that are outside the central nervous system. The term peripheral describes the anatomical distribution of this system, but functionally it is artificial. The cell bodies of peripheral motor fibres, for example, are located within the central nervous system. In experimental, clinical and epidemiological neurotoxicology, the term peripheral nervous system (PNS) describes a system that is selectively vulnerable to the effects of toxic agents and that is able to regenerate.

          The spinal nerves

          The ventral and dorsal roots are where the peripheral nerves enter and leave the spinal cord along its length. Adjoining vertebrae contain openings to allow root fibres forming the spinal nerves to leave the spinal canal. There are 31 pairs of spinal nerves, which are named according to the region of the vertebral column with which they are associated: 8 cervical, 12 thoracic, 5 lumbar, 5 sacral and 1 coccyxeal. A metamera is a region of the body innervated by a spinal nerve figure 5.

          Figure 5.    The segmental distribution of the spinal nerves (the metamera).

          NER020F9

          Carefully examining the motor and sensory functions of metamerae, neurologists can infer the location of lesions where damage has occurred.

           

           

           

           

           

           

           

          Table 1. Names and main functions of each pair of cranial nerves

          Nerve1 Conducts impulses Functions
          I. Olfactory From nose to brain Sense of smell
          II. Optic From eye to brain Vision
          III. Oculomotor From brain to eye muscles Eye movements
          IV. Trochlear From brain to external eye muscles Eye movements
          V. Trigeminal
          (or trifacial)
          From skin and mucous membrane of head and from teeth to brain; also from brain to chewing muscles Sensations of face, scalp and teeth; chewing movements
          VI. Abducens From brain to external eye muscles Turning eyes outward
          VII. Facial From taste buds of tongue to brain; from brain to face muscles Sense of taste; contraction of muscles of facial expression
          VIII. Acoustic From ear to brain Hearing; sense of balance
          IX. Glossopharyngeal From throat and taste buds of tongue to brain; also from brain to throat muscles and salivary glands Sensations of throat, taste, swallowing movements, secretion of saliva
          X. Vagus From throat, larynx, and organs in thoracic and abdominal cavities to brain; also from brain to muscles of throat and to organs in thoracic and abdominal cavities Sensations of throat, larynx, and for thoracic and abdominal organs; swallowing, voice production, slowing of heartbeat, acceleration of peristalsis
          XI. Spinal accessory From brain to certain shoulder and neck muscles Shoulder movements; turning movements of head
          XII. Hypoglossal From brain to muscles of tongue Tongue movements

          1 The first letter of the words of the following sentence are the first letters of the names of cranial nerves: “On Old Olympus’ Tiny Tops A Finn and German Viewed Some Hops”. Many generations of students have used this or a similar sentence to help them remember the names of cranial nerves.

           

          The cranial nerves

          Brain stem is a comprehensive term that designates the region of the nervous system that includes the medulla, the pons and the midbrain. The brain stem is a continuation of the spinal cord upward and forward (ventrally). It is in this region where most of the cranial nerves make their exits and entrances. There are 12 pairs of cranial nerves; Table 1 describes the name and main function of each pair and Figure 6 shows the entrance and exits of some cranial nerves in the brain.

          Figure 6.  The brain shown from below with the entrance and exits of many cranial nerves.

          NER020F8

          The Autonomic Nervous System

          The autonomic nervous system is that part of the nervous system controlling the activity of the visceral components of the human body. It is called “autonomic” because it performs its functions automatically, meaning that its functioning cannot be easily controlled at will. From an anatomical point of view, the autonomic system has two main components: the sympathetic and the parasympathetic nervous system. The sympathetic nerves controlling visceral activity arise from the thoracic and lumbar portions of the spinal cord; parasympathetic nerves arise from the brain stem and the sacral portion of the spinal cord.

          From a physiological point of view, no single generalization can be made that applies to the manner in which the sympathetic and the parasympathetic nervous systems control different body organs. In most cases, visceral organs are innervated by both systems, and each type has an opposite effect in a system of checks and balances. The heart, for example, is innervated by sympathetic nerves whose excitation produces an acceleration of the heartbeat, and by parasympathetic nerves whose excitation produce a slowing of the heartbeat. Either system can stimulate or inhibit the organs it innervates. In other cases, organs are predominantly or exclusively controlled by one system or the other. A vital function of the autonomic nervous system is the maintenance of homeostasis (stable state of equilibrium) and for the adaptation of the animal body to its external environment. Homeostasis is the state of equilibrium of body functions achieved by an active process; the control of body temperature, water and electrolytes are all examples of homeostatic processes.

          From the pharmacological point of view, there is no single neurotransmitter associated with either sympathetic or parasympathetic functions, as was once believed. The old view that acetylcholine was the predominant transmitter of the autonomic system had to be abandoned when new classes of neurotransmitters and neuromodulators were found (e.g., dopamine, serotonin, purines and various neuropeptides).

          Neuroscientists have recently revived the behavioural point of view of the autonomic nervous system. The autonomic nervous system is involved in the fight-or-flight instinctive reaction still present in humans, which is, for the most part, the basis for the physiological reactions caused by stress. Interactions between the nervous system and immunological functions are possible through the autonomic nervous system. Emotions that originate from the autonomic nervous system can be expressed via the skeletal muscles.

          The autonomic control of smooth muscles

          The muscles of the viscera—except for the heart—are the smooth muscles. Heart muscle has characteristics of both skeletal and smooth muscle. Like skeletal muscles, smooth muscles also contain the two proteins actin and, in smaller proportions, myosin. Unlike skeletal muscles, they do not present the regular organization of sarcolemes, the contractile unit of the muscle fibre. The heart is unique in that it can generate myogenic activity—even after its neural innervations have been severed, it can contract and relax for several hours by itself.

          The neuromuscular coupling in smooth muscles differs from that of skeletal muscles. In skeletal muscles, the neuromuscular junction is the link between the nerve and the muscle fibres. In smooth muscle, there is no neuromuscular junction; the nerve endings enter the muscle, spreading in all directions. Electrical events inside the smooth muscle therefore are much slower than those in skeletal muscles. Finally, smooth muscle has the unique characteristic of exhibiting spontaneous contractions, such as that exhibited by the gut. To a large extent, the autonomic nervous system regulates the smooth muscles’ spontaneous activity.

          The central components of the autonomic nervous system

          The main role of the autonomic nervous system is to regulate the activity of smooth muscles, heart, glands in the digestive tract, sweat glands, and adrenal and other endocrine glands. The autonomic nervous system has a central component—the hypothalamus, located at the base of the brain—where many autonomic functions are integrated. Most importantly, the central components of the autonomic system are directly involved in the regulation of biological drives (temperature regulation, hunger, thirst, sex, urination, defecation and so on), motivation, emotion and to a great extent in “psychological” functions such as moods, affect and feelings.

          Neuroendocrine System

          Glands are the organs of the endocrine system. They are called endocrine glands because their chemical messages are delivered inside the body, directly into the blood stream (in contrast with exocrine glands, such as sweat glands, whose secretions appear on the outer surface of the body). The endocrine system provides slow but long-lasting control over organs and tissues through chemical messengers called hormones. Hormones are the main regulators of body metabolism. But, because of intimate links among the central, peripheral, and autonomic nervous systems, the neuroendocrine system—a term that captures such complex links—is now conceived of as a powerful modifier of the structure and function of the human body and behaviour.

          Hormones have been defined as chemical messengers which are released from cells into the bloodstream to exert their action on target cells some distance away. Until recently, hormones were distinguished from neurotransmitters, discussed above. The latter are chemical messengers released from neurons onto a synapse between the nerve terminals and another neuron or an effector (i.e., muscle or gland). However, with the discovery that classical neurotransmitters such as dopamine can also act as hormones, the distinction between neurotransmitters and hormones is now less and less clear. Thus, based on purely anatomical considerations, hormones derived from nerve cells may be called neurohormones. From a functional point of view, the nervous system can be thought of as a truly neurosecretory system.

          The hypothalamus controls endocrine functions through a link with the pituitary gland (also called the hypophysis, a tiny gland located at the base of the brain). Until the middle 1950s the endocrine glands were viewed as a separate system governed by the pituitary gland, often called the “master gland”. At that time, a neurovascular hypothesis was advanced that established the functional role of the hypothalamic/hypophysial factors in the control of endocrine function. In this view, the endocrine hypothalamus provides the final common neuroendocrine pathway in the control of the endocrine system. It has now been firmly established that the endocrine system is itself regulated by the central nervous system as well as the endocrine inputs. Thus, neuroendocrinology is now an appropriate term to describe the discipline that studies the reciprocal integrated roles of the nervous and the endocrine systems in the control of physiological processes.

          With increasing understanding of neuroendocrinology, original divisions are breaking down. The hypothalamus, which is located above and connected to the pituitary gland, is the link between the nervous and the endocrine systems, and many of its nerve cells perform secretory functions. It is also linked with other major regions of the brain, including the rhinencephalon—the primitive cortex originally associated with olfaction or sense of smell—and the limbic system, associated with emotions. It is in the hypothalamus that hormones released by the posterior pituitary gland are produced. The hypothalamus also produces substances that are called releasing and inhibiting hormones. These act on the adenohypophysis, causing it to enhance or inhibit the production of anterior pituitary gland hormones, which act on glands located elsewhere (thyroid, adrenal cortex, ovaries, testicles and others).

           

          Back

          Thursday, 17 February 2011 21:55

          Nervous System: Overview

          Knowledge of the nervous system in general and of the brain and human behaviour in particular are of paramount importance to those who are dedicated to a safe and healthy environment. Work conditions, and exposures that directly affect the operations of the brain, influence the mind and behaviour. To evaluate information, to make decisions and to react in a consistent and reasonable manner to perceptions of the world require that the nervous system functions properly and that behaviour not be damaged by dangerous conditions, such as accidents (e.g., a fall from a poorly designed ladder) or exposure to hazardous levels of neurotoxic chemicals.

          Damage to the nervous system can cause changes in sensory input (loss of vision, hearing, smell, etc.), can hinder the capacity to control movement and body functions and/or can affect the brain’s capacity to treat or store information. In addition, altered nervous system functioning can cause behavioural or psychological disorders. Mood and personality changes are a common occurrence following physical or organic damage to the brain. As our knowledge develops, we are learning more about the way in which nervous system processes are modified. Neurotoxic substances can cross the brain’s natural barrier and directly interfere with its intricate workings. Although some substances have a particular affinity to certain areas of the nervous system, most neurotoxins have widespread effects, targeting cell processes involved in membrane transport, internal cellular chemical reactions, liberation of secretory substances, and so on.

          Damage to the various components of the nervous system can occur in different ways:

          • direct physical injury from falling objects, collisions, blows or undue pressure on nerves
          • changes in the internal environment, such as insufficient oxygen due to asphyxiants and heat exposure
          • interference in the cellular processes through chemical action by substances, such as metals, organic solvents and pesticides

           

          The insidious and multifaceted development of many nervous system disorders requires persons working in the field of occupational health to adopt different but complementary approaches to the study, understanding, prevention and treatment of the problem. Early alterations can be detected in groups of active, exposed workers using sensitive measures of impairment. Identification of initial dysfunction can lead to preventive actions. In the latter stages, a good clinical knowledge is required and differential diagnosis is essential to the adequate treatment and care of disabled workers.

          Although chemical substances are mostly examined one by one, it should be remembered that in many workplaces mixtures of potentially neurotoxic chemicals are used, exposing workers to what can be called a “cocktail”. In processes such as printing, painting, cleaning, in poorly ventilated offices, in laboratories, pesticide application, microelectronics and many other sectors, workers are exposed to chemical mixtures. Although there may be information on each one of the substances separately, we have to consider the combined nocivity and possible additive or even synergistic effects on the nervous system. In some cases of multiple exposure, each particular chemical may be present in very small quantity, even below the detection level of exposure assessment techniques; however, when all are added together, the total concentration can be very high.

          The reader should be aware of three major difficulties in reviewing facts about the nervous system within the scope of this Encyclopaedia.

          First, the understanding of occupational diseases affecting the nervous system and behaviour has changed substantially as new approaches to viewing brain-behavioural relationships have developed. The main interest of characterization of gross morphological changes that occur due to mechanical trauma to the nervous system—particularly, but not exclusively to the brain—was followed by an interest in the absorption of neurotoxic agents by the nervous system; interest in the study of cellular mechanisms of nervous system pathology; and finally, the search for the molecular basis of these pathologic processes began to grow. These approaches coexist today and all contribute information for evaluating the working conditions affecting the brain, mind, and behaviour.

          Second, the information generated by neuroscientists is staggering. The third edition of the book Principles of Neural Sciences edited by Kandel, Schwartz and Kessell which appeared in 1991—one of the most valuable reviews of the field—weighs 3.5 kg and is more than 1,000 pages long.

          Third, it is very difficult to review knowledge about the functional organization of the nervous system as it applies to all niches of occupational health and safety. Until about 25 years ago, the theoretical views that gave support to those concerned health experts who specialize in the detection, monitoring, prevention, and the clinical treatment of a worker who has absorbed a neurotoxic agent sometimes did not overlap with theoretical views regarding workers’ brain trauma and the behavioural manifestations of minimal brain damage. Behavioural manifestations said to be the consequence of the disruption of specific chemical pathways in the brain were the exclusive territory of the neurotoxicologist; both structural tissue damage of specific regions of the brain, and distant neural structures linked to the area where the lesions occurred, were explanations invoked by neurologists. It is only in the past few years that converging views are appearing.

          With this in mind, this chapter addresses issues important to the understanding of the nervous system and the effects of workplace conditions on its functioning. It begins with a description of the anatomy and physiology, followed by a section on neurotoxicity, which reviews exposure, outcomes and prevention.

          Since the nervous system is central to the body’s well-being, many non-chemical hazards can likewise affect its normal functioning. Many of these are considered in different chapters dealing with these hazards. Traumatic head injuries are included in First Aid, heat stress is considered in the article “Effects of heat stress and work in the heat”, and decompression sickness is reviewed in the article “Gravitational stress”. Hand-arm vibration (“Hand-transmitted vibration”) and repetitive movement (“Chronic outcomes, musculoskeletal”) in the chapter Musculoskeletal System, which are risk factors for peripheral neuropathies, are likewise considered in these sections of the Encyclopaedia.

          The chapter ends with a review of special issues and the outlook for future research avenues.

           

          Back

          Thursday, 17 February 2011 00:15

          General Lighting Conditions

          Lighting is provided within interiors in order to satisfy the following requirements:

          • to assist in providing a safe working environment
          • to assist in the performance of visual tasks
          • to develop an appropriate visual environment.

           

          The provision of a safe working environment has to be at the top of the list of priorities, and, in general, safety is increased by making hazards clearly visible. The order of priority of the other two requirements will depend to a large extent upon the use to which the interior is put. Task performance can be improved by ensuring that task detail is easier to see, while appropriate visual environments are developed by varying the lighting emphasis given to objects and surfaces within an interior.

          Our general feeling of well-being, including morale and fatigue, is influenced by light and colour. Under low lighting levels, objects would have little or no colour or shape and there would be a loss in perspective. Conversely an excess of light may be just as unwanted as too little light.

          In general, people prefer a room with daylight to a room which is windowless. Furthermore, contact with the outside world is considered to aid the feeling of well-being. The introduction of automatic lighting controls, together with high-frequency dimming of fluorescent lamps, has made it possible to provide interiors with a controlled combination of daylight and artificial light. This has the added benefit of saving on energy costs.

          Perception of the character of an interior is influenced by both the brightness and colour of visible surfaces, both interior and exterior. The general lighting conditions within an interior can be achieved by using daylight or artificial lighting, or more likely by a combination of both.

          Evaluation of Lighting

          General requirements

          Lighting systems used in commercial interiors can be sub-divided into three major categories—general lighting, localized lighting and local lighting.

          General lighting installations typically provide an approximately uniform illuminance over the whole of the working plane. Such systems are often based upon the lumen method of design, where an average illuminance is:

          Average illuminance (lux) =

          Localized lighting systems provide illuminance on general work areas with a simultaneous reduced level of illuminance in adjacent areas.

          Local lighting systems provide illuminance for relatively small areas incorporating visual tasks. Such systems are normally complemented by a specified level of general lighting. Figure 1 illustrates the typical differences between the systems described.

          Figure 1. Lighting systems

          LIG030F1

          Where visual tasks are to be performed it is essential to achieve a demanded level of illuminance and to consider the circumstances that influence its quality.

          The use of daylight to illuminate tasks has both merits and limitations. Windows admitting daylight into an interior provide good three-dimensional modelling, and though the spectral distribution of daylight varies throughout the day, its colour rendering is generally considered to be excellent.

          However, a constant illuminance on a task cannot be provided by natural daylight only, due to its wide variability, and if the task is within the same field of view as a bright sky, then disabling glare is likely to occur, thereby impairing task performance. The use of daylight for task illuminance has only partial success, and artificial lighting, over which greater control can be exercised, has a major role to play.

          Since the human eye will perceive surfaces and objects only through light which is reflected from them, it follows that surface characteristics and reflectance values together with the quantity and quality of light will influence the appearance of the                                                                                                                                       environment.

          When considering the lighting of an interior it is essential to determine the illuminance level and to compare it with recommended levels for different tasks (see table 1).

          Table 1. Typical recommended levels of maintained illuminance for different locations or visual tasks


          Location/Task

          Typical recommended level of maintained illuminance (lux)

          General offices

          500

          Computer workstations

          500

          Factory assembly areas

           

          Rough work

          300

          Medium work

          500

          Fine work

          750

          Very fine work

           

          Instrument assembly

          1,000

          Jewellery assembly/repairs

          1,500

          Hospital operating theatres

          50,000

           

          Lighting for visual tasks

          The ability of the eye to discern detail—visual acuity—is significantly influenced by task size, contrast and the viewer’s visual performance. Increase in the quantity and quality of lighting will also significantly improve visual performance. The effect of lighting on task performance is influenced by the size of the critical details of the task and upon the contrast between task and surrounding background. Figure 2 shows the effects of illuminance upon visual acuity. When considering visual task lighting it is important to consider the ability of the eye to carry out the visual task with both speed and accuracy. This combination is known as visual performance. Figure 3 gives typical effects of illuminance on the visual performance of a given task.

          Figure 2. Typical relationship between visual acuity and illuminance

          LIG030F2

          Figure 3. Typical relationship between visual performance and illuminance

          LIG030F3

          The prediction of illuminance reaching a working surface is of prime importance in lighting design. However, the human visual system responds to the distribution of luminance within the field of view. The scene within a visual field is interpreted by differentiating between surface colour, reflectance and illumination. Luminance depends upon both the illuminance on, and reflectance of, a surface. Both illuminance and luminance are objective quantities. The response to brightness, however, is subjective.

           

           

           

           

          In order to produce an environment which provides visual satisfaction, comfort and performance, luminances within the field of view need to be balanced. Ideally the luminances surrounding a task should decrease gradually, thereby avoiding harsh contrasts. Suggested variation in luminance across a task is shown in figure 4.

          Figure 4. Variation in luminance across a task

          LIG030F4

          The lumen method of lighting design leads to an average horizontal plane illuminance on the working plane, and it is possible to use the method to establish average illuminance values on the walls and ceilings within an interior. It is possible to convert average illuminance values into average luminance values from details of the mean reflectance value of the room surfaces.

           

           

           

          The equation relating luminance and illuminance is: 

          Figure 5. Typical relative illuminance values together with suggested reflectance values

          LIG030F5

          Figure 5 shows a typical office with relative illuminance values (from an overhead general lighting system) on the main room surfaces together with suggested reflectances. The human eye tends to be drawn to that part of the visual scene which is brightest. It follows that higher luminance values usually occur at a visual task area. The eye acknowledges detail within a visual task by discriminating between lighter and darker parts of the task. The variation in brightness of a visual task is determined from calculation of the luminance contrast:

          where

          Lt = Luminance of the task

          Lb = Luminance of the background

          and both luminances are measured in cd·m–2

          The vertical lines in this equation signify that all values of luminance contrast are to be considered positive.

          The contrast of a visual task will be influenced by the reflectance properties of the task itself. See figure 5.

          Optical Control of Lighting

          If a bare lamp is used in a luminaire, the distribution of light is unlikely to be acceptable and the system will almost certainly be uneconomical. In such situations the bare lamp is likely to be a source of glare to the room occupants, and while some light may eventually reach the working plane, the effectiveness of the installation is likely to be seriously reduced because of the glare.

          It will be evident that some form of light control is required, and the methods most frequently employed are detailed below.

          Obstruction

          If a lamp is installed within an opaque enclosure with only a single aperture for the light to escape, then the light distribution will be very limited, as shown in figure 6.

          Figure 6. Lighting output control by obstruction

          LIG030F6

          Reflection

          This method uses reflective surfaces, which may vary from a highly matt finish to a highly specular or mirror-like finish. This method of control is more efficient than obstruction, since stray light is collected and redirected to where it is required. The principle involved is shown in figure 7.

          Figure 7. Light output control by reflection

          LIG030F7

          Diffusion

          If a lamp is installed within a translucent material, the apparent size of the light source is increased with a simultaneous reduction in its brightness. Practical diffusers unfortunately absorb some of the emitted light, which consequently reduces the overall efficiency of the luminaire. Figure 8 illustrates the principle of diffusion.

          Figure 8. Light output control by diffusion

          LIG030F8

          Refraction

          This method uses the “prism” effect, where typically a prism material of glass or plastic “bends” the rays of light and in so doing redirects the light to where it is required. This method is extremely suitable for general interior lighting. It has the advantage of combining good glare control with an acceptable efficiency. Figure 9 shows how refraction assists in optical control.

          In many cases a luminaire will use a combination of the methods of optical control described.

          Figure 9. Light output control by refraction

          LIG030F9

          Luminance distribution

          The light output distribution from a luminaire is significant in determining the visual conditions subsequently experienced. Each of the four methods of optical control described will produce differing light output distribution properties from the luminaire.

          Veiling reflections often occur in areas where VDUs are installed. The usual symptoms experienced in such situations are reduced ability to read correctly from the text on a screen due to the appearance of unwanted high-luminance images on the screen itself, typically from overhead luminaires. A situation can develop where veiling reflections also appear on paper on a desk in an interior.

          If the luminaires in an interior have a strong vertically downward component of light output, then any paper on a desk beneath such a luminaire will reflect the light source into the eyes of an observer who is reading from or working on the paper. If the paper has a gloss finish, the situation is aggravated.

          The solution to the problem is to arrange for the luminaires used to have a light output distribution which is predominantly at an angle to the downward vertical, so that following the basic laws of physics (angle of incidence = angle of reflection) the reflected glare will be minimized. Figure 10 shows a typical example of both the problem and the cure. The light output distribution from the luminaire used to overcome the problem is referred to as a batwing distribution.

          Figure 10. Veiling reflections

          LIG30F10

          Light distribution from luminaires can also lead to direct glare, and in an attempt to overcome this problem, local lighting units should be installed outside the 45-degree “forbidden angle”, as shown in figure 11.

          Figure 11. Diagrammatic representation of the forbidden angle

          LIG30F11

          Optimal Lighting Conditions for Visual Comfortand Performance

          It is appropriate when investigating lighting conditions for visual comfort and performance to consider those factors affecting the ability to see detail. These can be sub-divided into two categories—characteristics of the observer and characteristics of the task.

          Characteristics of the observer.

          These include:

          • sensitivity of the individual’s visual system to size, contrast, exposure time
          • transient adaptation characteristics
          • susceptibility to glare
          • age
          • motivational and psychological characteristics.

           

          Characteristics of the task.

          These include:

          • configuration of detail
          • contrast of detail/background
          • background luminance
          • specularity of detail.

           

          With reference to particular tasks, the following questions need to be answered:

          • Are the task details easy to see?
          • Is the task likely to be undertaken for lengthy periods?
          • If errors result from the performance of the task, are the consequences considered to be serious?

           

          In order to produce optimal workplace lighting conditions it is important to consider the requirements placed upon the lighting installation. Ideally task lighting should reveal colour, size, relief and surface qualities of a task while simultaneously avoiding the creation of potentially dangerous shadows, glare and “harsh” surroundings to the task itself.

          Glare.

          Glare occurs when there is excessive luminance in the field of view. The effects of glare on vision can be divided into two groups, termed disability glare and discomfort glare.

          Consider the example of glare from the headlights of an oncoming vehicle during darkness. The eye cannot adapt simultaneously to the headlights of the vehicle and to the much lower brightness of the road. This is an example of disability glare, since the high luminance light sources produce a disabling effect due to the scattering of light in the optic media. Disability glare is proportional to the intensity of the offending source of light.

          Discomfort glare, which is more likely to occur in interiors, can be reduced or even totally eliminated by reducing the contrast between the task and its surroundings. Matt, diffusely reflecting finishes on work surfaces are to be preferred to gloss or specularly reflecting finishes, and the position of any offending light source should be outside the normal field of vision. In general, successful visual performance occurs when the task itself is brighter than its immediate surrounds, but not excessively.

          The magnitude of discomfort glare is given a numerical value and compared with reference values in order to predict whether the level of discomfort glare will be acceptable. The method of calculation of glare index values used in the UK and elsewhere is considered under “Measurement”.

          Measurement

          Lighting surveys

          One survey technique often used relies upon a grid of measuring points over the whole area under consideration. The basis of this technique is to divide the whole of the interior into a number of equal areas, each ideally square. The illuminance at the centre of each of the areas is measured at desk-top height (typically 0.85 metres above floor level), and an average value of illuminance is calculated. The accuracy of the value of average illuminance is influenced by the number of measuring points used.

          A relationship exists which enables the minimum number of measuring points to be calculated from the value of room index applicable to the interior under consideration.

          Here, length and width refer to the room dimensions, and mounting height is the vertical distance between the centre of the light source and the working plane.

          The relationship referred to is given as:

          Minimum number of measuring points = (x + 2)2

          where “x” is the value of the room index taken to the next highest whole number, except that for all values of RI equal to or greater than 3, x is taken as 4. This equation gives the minimum number of measuring points, but conditions often require more than this minimum number of points to be used.

          When considering the lighting of a task area and its immediate surround, variance in illuminance or uniformity of illuminance must be considered.

          Over any task area and its immediate surround, uniformity should be not less than 0.8.

          In many workplaces it is unnecessary to illuminate all areas to the same level. Localized or local lighting may provide some degree of energy saving, but whichever system is used the variance in illuminance across an interior must not be excessive.

          The diversity of illuminance is expressed as:

          At any point in the major area of the interior, the diversity of illuminance should not exceed 5:1.

          Instruments used for measuring illuminance and luminance typically have spectral responses which vary from the response of the human visual system. The responses are corrected, often by the use of filters. When filters are incorporated, the instruments are referred to as colour corrected.

          Illuminance meters have a further correction applied which compensates for the direction of incident light falling upon the detector cell. Instruments which are capable of accurately measuring illuminance from varying directions of incident light are said to be cosine corrected.

          Measurement of glare index

          The system used frequently in the UK, with variations elsewhere, is essentially a two-stage process. The first stage establishes an uncorrected glare index value (UGI). Figure 12 provides an example.

          Figure 12. Elevation and plan views of typical interior used in example

          LIG30F12

          The height H is the vertical distance between the centre of the light source and the eye level of a seated observer, which is normally taken as 1.2 metres above floor level. The major dimensions of the room are then converted into multiples of H. Thus, since H = 3.0 metres, then length = 4H and width = 3H. Four separate calculations of UGI have to be made in order to determine the worst case scenario in accordance with the layouts shown in figure 13.

          Figure 13. Possible combinations of luminaire orientation and viewing direction within the interior considered in the example

          LIG30F13

          Tables are produced by lighting equipment manufacturers which specify, for given values of fabric reflectance within a room, values of uncorrected glare index for each combination of values of X and Y.

          The second stage of the process is to apply correction factors to the UGI values depending upon values of lamp output flux and deviation in value of height (H).

          The final glare index value is then compared with the Limiting Glare Index value for specific interiors, given in references such as the CIBSE Code for Interior Lighting (1994).

           

          Back

          Wednesday, 16 February 2011 23:53

          Other Diseases

          Primary Fibromyalgia

          The cause of fibromyalgia is not known. Some patients associate trauma and infections with the development of symptoms, but there is no hard evidence in favour of such triggering events. However, many factors are known to aggravate the existing symptoms. Cold, damp weather, mental disturbance, physical or mental stress, and also physical inactivity have all been associated with fibromyalgia (Wolfe 1986).

          A major feature is patients waking up in the morning feeling tired. Abnormal serotonin metabolism is associated with both the sleep disturbance and decreased pain threshold typical in these patients (Goldberg 1987).

          The symptoms of fibromyalgia start insidiously with persisting widespread musculoskeletal pains, multiple general symptoms such as fatigue, stiffness, subjective swelling of the fingers not observed by the examining physician, non-refreshing sleep and muscular pain after exertion. About one-third of the patients have additional symptoms, such as irritable bowel syndrome, tension headaches, premenstrual syndrome, numbness and tingling in the extremities, dryness of mouth and eyes and constriction of the blood vessels in the fingers when exposed to cold (Raynaud’s phenomenon).

          Typically, a patient with fibromyalgia has a large variety of symptoms, which, with the exception of tender points, have no objective counterparts. Fibromyalgia runs a chronic course. Most of the patients continue to have symptoms with varying intensity. Complete remission is an exception. In primary fibromyalgia, no laboratory signs referring to inflammatory arthritis are present. Patients with inflammatory arthritis (e.g. rheumatoid arthritis) can also have fibromyalgic symptoms, in which case the term secondary fibromyalgia is applied.

          There is no one test for fibromyalgia. The diagnosis of fibro- myalgia is based on the history of the patient and on the clinical observation of tender points (figure 1). The prevalence of fibro-myalgia in the general population is 0.5 to 1%. Most (75 to 90%) of the patients are women, usually between 25 and 45 years of age; children are rarely affected.

          Figure 1. Tender point sites in fibromyalgia.

          MUS170F1

          The American College of Rheumatology has set criteria for the classification of fibromyalgia (figure 2).

          Figure 2. The American College of Rheumatology 1990 criteria for the diagnosis of fibromyalgia.

          MUS170T1

          Diagnosis

          Other ailments with similar symptoms must be excluded. Widespread pain must be present for at least three months. In addition there must be pain in 11 of the 18 tender point sites shown in figure 1 when pressed by an examiner’s finger.

          Rheumatoid Arthritis

          About 1% of the adult population has rheumatoid arthritis. The onset of the disease is usually at 30 to 50 years of age, with females having a threefold higher risk than males. The prevalence of the disease increases in older populations.

          The cause of rheumatoid arthritis is not known. It is not inherited, but genetic factors increase the risk for the development of the disease. In addition to one or multiple genetic factors, some environmental triggering factors are thought to play a role in its pathogenesis, and viral or bacterial infections are heavily suspected.

          Rheumatoid arthritis usually starts gradually. Typically, the patient has mild swelling of the small joints of fingers, and tenderness of the feet that manifests in a symmetrical fashion. If joints on one hand, for example, are involved it is likely that the same joints on the other hand will be affected. Stiffness of hands and feet in the morning is a major symptom. The patient often has fatigue and can have mild fever. Laboratory features include evidence of inflammation (elevated erythrocyte sedimentation rate and C-reactive protein level) and often mild anaemia. About 70% of the patients have circulating rheumatoid factor (autoantibody against IgG-class immunoglobulin). In early cases, radiological examination of hands and feet is often normal, but later on, most patients develop radiological evidence of joint destruction (erosions). The diagnosis of rheumatoid arthritis is based on a mixture of clinical, laboratory and radiological findings (see figure 3).

          Figure 3. Criteris for the diagnosis of rheumatoid arthritis.

          MUS170T2

          The diseases which most often cause differential diagnostic problems are degenerative joint diseases of the hands, arthritis following infections, spondylarthropathies, and some rare connective tissue diseases (Guidelines 1992).

          Patient education to diminish the work-load of the joints, use of ergonomic appliances, good footwear, and proper treatment of infections form the basis of preventive measures. Treatment guidelines are given in table 1.

          Table 1. Guidelines for the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis

          1.

          Treatment of joint pain

          Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs

          Acetaminophen (Dextropropoxyphen)

          2.

          Treatment of joint inflammation (disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs)

          Intramuscular gold

          Sulfasalazine

          Auranofin

          Antimalarials

          D-penicillamine

          Methotrexate

          Azathioprine

          Cyclosporine (Cyclophosphamide)

          Glucocorticosteroid therapy

          3.

          Local injections

          Glucocorticosteroid

          Chemical synovectomy osmium tetroxide

          Injection of radioactive isotopes

          4.

          Surgery

          Early reparative surgery (synovectomy, tenosynovectomy)

          Reconstructive surgery

          5.

          Rehabilitation

          Occupational therapy

          Physiotherapy

          Education

          Evaluation of needs of aids and appliances

           

          Spondylarthropathies

          Epidemiology and aetiology

          Spondylarthropathies include typical clinical entities such as ankylosing spondylitis and some forms of arthritides associated with psoriasis, with chronic inflammatory bowel diseases, or with bacterial infections in the urogenital tract or in the gut (so called reactive arthritis). The diseases are common. The prevalence of the most chronic form, ankylosing spondylitis, in Western populations varies between 0.1 and 1.8% (Gran and Husby 1993). Three new cases of transient arthritis such as reactive arthritis compared to one patient with ankylosing spondylitis are estimated to occur annually in a population of 10,000. Most of the patients who develop spondylarthropathy are young adults, between 20 and 40 years of age. There is evidence that the mean onset of symptoms for patients with ankylosing spondylitis is increasing (Calin et al. 1988).

          Spondylarthropathies have a strong genetic component since a majority of the patients have an inherited genetic marker, HLA-B27. The frequency of this marker is about 7 to 15% in Western populations; 90 to 100% of patients with ankylosing spondylitis and 70 to 90% of patients with reactive arthritis are HLA-B27 positive. However, at population levels, most of the subjects with this marker are healthy. Therefore, it is thought that exogenous factors, in addition to the genetic susceptibility, are needed for the development of the disease. Such triggering factors include bacterial infections in the urogenital tract or in the gut (table 2) skin lesions, and chronic inflammatory bowel diseases. The evidence in favour of infections is most direct in the case of reactive arthritis. Salmonella infections are widely increasing, as a sequel of which an increase in the cases with joint complications can be expected. Agriculture and poultry can be the sources of these infections. As to yersinia infections, pigs harbour yersinia bacteria in their tonsils. Slaughtering followed by storage of the meat products in the cold has been suggested to contribute to the dispersion of infections in humans. In patients with ankylosing spondylitis, however, usually no preceding infections can be traced as an initiating event. Recent results have, however, focused on the finding that patients with ankylosing spondylitis often have asymptomatic chronic gut inflammation, which could serve as a triggering factor or as a contributing inflammatory focus in the chronicity of the disease.

          Table 2. Infections known to trigger reactive arthritis

          Focus

          Bacteria

          Upper respiratory tract

          Chlamydia pneumoniae

          Beta-haemolytic streptococcus (usually causes rheumatic fever)

          Gut

          Salmonella

          Shigella

          Yersinia enterocolitica

          Yersinia pseudotuberculosis

          Campylobacter jejuni

          Urogenital tract

          Chlamydia trachomatis

          Neisseria gonorrhoeae

           

          Signs and symptoms

          Peripheral arthritis is asymmetric, affects large joints, and has a predilection to low extremities. The patients often also have inflammatory low back pain, worse by night and relieved by movement, not by rest. A typical feature is a tendency to inflammation of the junction between tendons and bones (enthesopathy), which can manifest itself as pain under the heel or in calcaneus at the insertion of Achilles tendon. In addition to inflammation in the joints and at ligamentous insertions, patients also can have inflammatory symptoms in eyes (iritis or conjunctivitis), skin (psoriasis, skin lesions in palms, soles, or leg induration) and sometimes in the heart.

          The following are the diagnostic criteria for spondylarthro- pathy (Dougados et al. 1991).

          Inflammatory low back pain

          or

          Joint inflammation (synovitis):

          • asymmetric
          • predilection to low extremities

          and

          at least one of the following:

          • positive family history for spondylarthropathy
          • psoriasis
          • inflammatory bowel disease
          • buttock pain changing from side to side
          • pain at the junction between tendon and bone (enthesopathy).

           

          Patients with ankylosing spondylitis have low-back pain, worse by night, and tenderness between the spine and the pelvis at the sacroiliac joints. They can have limited mobility of the spine with chest tenderness. A third of the patients have peripheral arthritis and enthesopathy. The cornerstone of the diagnosis of ankylosing spondylitis is the presence of radiological changes in the sacroiliac joints; there is a loss of space between the joints, and bony outgrowths. Such changes add to the diagnostic accuracy of patients with spondylarthropathy but are necessary only in the case of ankylosing spondylitis.

          Gout

          Epidemiology and aetiology

          Gout is a metabolic disorder that is the most common cause of inflammatory arthritis in men. Its prevalence among adults varies from 0.2 to 0.3 per 1000, and is 1.5% in adult males. The prevalence of gout increases with age and with increasing serum urate levels.

          Hyperuricemia (high level of uric acid in serum) is a risk factor. Contributing factors are chronic kidney diseases which lead to renal insufficiency, hypertension, use of diuretic drugs, high alcohol intake, lead exposure and obesity. Gouty attacks are precipitated by hypersaturation of joint fluid with uric acid; the precipitated crystals irritate the joint, with the development of acute arthritis.

          Signs and symptoms

          The natural course of gout runs through several stages from a- symptomatic hyperuricemia to acute gouty arthritis, asymptomatic periods, and to chronic tophaceous gout (gout with nodules).

          Acute gouty arthritis often manifests itself as an acute inflammation in one joint, usually at the base of the big toe. The joint is very tender, swollen and highly painful; it is often red. The acute attack can subside spontaneously within days. If untreated, repeated attacks can occur, and in some patients these continue (during the subsequent years) so that the patient develops chronic arthritis. In these patients, urate deposits can be observed in the ear helices, at the elbows, or at the Achilles tendons, where they form non-tender subcutaneous palpable masses (tophi).

          Infectious Arthritis

          Epidemiology and aetiology

          In children, infectious arthritis often develops in a previously healthy child, but adults often have some predisposing factor, such as diabetes, chronic arthritis, use of glucocorticosteroid or immunosuppressive therapy, previous injections or trauma in the joint. Patients with endoprosthesis are also susceptible to infections in the operated joint.

          Bacteria are most often the cause of infectious arthritis. In immunosuppressed patients, fungi can be found. Although bacterial infection in the joint is rare, it is very important to recognize, because, if untreated, the infection rapidly destroys the joint. The microbes can reach the joint by circulation (septic infection), by direct penetrating wound or during a joint injection, or from an adjacent infectious focus.

          Signs and symptoms

          In a typical case, a patient has acute joint inflammation, usually in one single joint, which is painful, hot, red and tender to movement. There are general symptoms of infection (fever, chills) and laboratory evidence of acute inflammation. The joint aspiration is turbid, and in microscopic examination a high number of white blood cells are seen, with positive stain and cultures for bacteria. The patient can have signs of a focus of infection elsewhere, such as pneumonia.

          Osteoporosis

          Epidemiology and aetiology

          Bone mass increases from childhood until adolescence. Women gain 15% less bone density than men. It is at its highest between 20 and 40 years, after which there is a constant decrease. Osteoporosis is a condition in which bone mass decreases and bones become susceptible to fracture. Osteoporosis is a major cause of morbidity in the elderly. The most important manifestation is lumbar and hip fractures. About 40% of women who have reached 70 years have suffered from fractures.

          Peak bone mass is influenced by genetic factors. In women, bone mass decreases after menopause. The decrease of bone mass in men is less distinct than in women. In addition to lack of oestrogen, other factors influence the rate of bone loss and the development of osteoporosis. These include physical inactivity, low amount of calcium in the diet, smoking, coffee consumption and low body weight. Use of systemic corticosteroid therapy is also associated with enhanced risk for osteoporosis.

          Signs and symptoms

          Osteoporosis can be asymptomatic. On the other hand, the most distinct manifestation of osteoporosis is bone fracture, typically that of the hip, vertebrae (spine) and wrist. Hip and wrist fractures usually are a result of falling, but vertebral fractures can develop insidiously after a trivial trauma. The patient has back pain, kyphosis and loss of height.

          Bone Cancer

          Epidemiology and aetiology

          Primary malignant bone tumours are uncommon. They occur most often in children and young adults. Osteosarcoma is the most frequent of the malignant bone tumours. It is most frequently observed in the second decade of life, and in older adults it can result secondary to a bone disease (Paget’s disease). Ewing’s sarcoma is also mostly observed in children, who present with destructive changes in the pelvis or in the long bones. Malignant tumours originating from the cartilage (chondrosarcoma) can occur in many cartilage areas. In adults, malignant bone lesions are often metastatic (i.e., the primary malignant disease is somewhere else in the body).

          Most malignant primary tumours have no known aetiology. However, Paget’s disease of bone, osteomyelitis, osteonecrosis and radiation injury have been associated with malignant transformation. Bone metastases are frequent in primary cancers of the breast, lung, prostate, kidney or thyroid gland.

          Signs and symptoms

          Pain, limitation of movement and swelling are present in patients with osteosarcoma. In addition to bone pain, patients with Ewing’s sarcoma often have systemic symptoms such as fever, malaise and chills. Chondrosarcomas can cause varying symptoms depending on the site of the tumour and its histologic details.

          Osteomyelitis

          Epidemiology and aetiology

          Osteomyelitis is a bone infection that is usually bacterial, but can be fungal or viral. In an otherwise healthy person, osteomyelitis is a rare event, but in patients with chronic diseases such as diabetes or rheumatoid arthritis, infection in the body can spread by the bloodstream or by direct invasion to bones. In children, the most favoured site for the spreading is the shaft of long bone, but in adults the infection is often in the spine. A focal point from which an infection can spread by bloodstream or by direct invasion, penetrating or blunt trauma, prior orthopaedic surgery (insertion of prosthesis) can all be complicated by osteomyelitis.

          Signs and symptoms

          Acute bone infection of the long bones is associated with fever, chills and bone pain. Spinal osteomyelitis can cause more vague symptoms with progressive pain and low-grade fever. Infections around a prosthesis cause pain and tenderness when moving the operated joint.

           

          Back

          Wednesday, 16 February 2011 23:43

          Conditions Required for Visual Comfort

          Human beings possess an extraordinary capacity to adapt to their environment and to their immediate surroundings. Of all the types of energy that humans can utilize, light is the most important. Light is a key element in our capacity to see, and it is necessary to appreciate the form, the colour and the perspective of the objects that surround us in our daily lives. Most of the information we obtain through our senses we obtain through sight—close to 80%. Very often, and because we are so used to having it available, we take it for granted. We should not fail to keep in mind, however, that aspects of human welfare, like our state of mind or our level of fatigue, are affected by illumination and the colour of the things that surround us. From the point of view of safety at work, visual capacity and visual comfort are extraordinarily important. This is because many accidents are due to, among other reasons, illumination deficiencies or errors made by the worker because he or she finds it hard to identify objects or the risks associated with machinery, conveyances, dangerous containers and so on.

          Visual disorders associated with deficiencies in the illumination system are common in the workplace. Due to the ability of sight to adapt to situations with deficient lighting, these aspects are sometimes not considered as seriously as they should be.

          The correct design of an illumination system should offer the optimal conditions for visual comfort. For the attainment of this goal an early line of collaboration between architects, lighting designers and those responsible for hygiene at the worksite should be established. This collaboration should precede the beginning of the project, to avoid errors that would be difficult to correct once the project is completed. Among the most important aspects that should be kept in mind are the type of lamp that will be used and the lighting system that will be installed, the distribution of luminance, illumination efficiencies and the spectral composition of light.

          The fact that light and colour affect the productivity and the psycho-physiological well-being of the worker should encourage the initiatives of illumination technicians, physiologists and ergonomists, to study and determine the most favourable conditions of light and colour at each work station. The combination of illumination, the contrast of luminances, the colour of light, the reproduction of colour or the selection of colours are the elements that determine colour climate and visual comfort.

          Factors that Determine Visual Comfort

          The prerequisites that an illumination system must fulfil in order to provide the conditions necessary for visual comfort are the following:

          • uniform illumination
          • optimal luminance
          • no glare
          • adequate contrast conditions
          • correct colours
          • absence of stroboscopic effect or intermittent light.

           

          It is important to consider light in the workplace not only by quantitative criteria, but also by qualitative criteria. The first step is to study the work station, the precision required of the tasks performed, the amount of work, the mobility of the worker and so on. Light should include components both of diffuse and of direct radiation. The result of the combination will produce shadows of greater or lesser intensity that will allow the worker to perceive the form and position of objects at the work station. Annoying reflections, which make it harder to perceive details, should be eliminated, as well as excessive glare or deep shadows.

          The periodic maintenance of the lighting installation is very important. The goal is to prevent the ageing of lamps and the accumulation of dust on the luminaries that will result in a constant loss of light. For this reason it is important to select lamps and systems that are easy to maintain. An incandescent light bulb maintains its efficiency until the moments before failure, but this is not the case with fluorescent tubes, which may lower their output down to 75% after a thousand hours of use.

          Levels of illumination

          Each activity requires a specific level of illumination in the area where the activity takes place. In general, the higher the difficulty for visual perception, the higher the average level of illumination should be as well. Guidelines for minimal levels of illumination associated with different tasks exist in various publications. Concretely, those listed in figure 1 have been gleaned from European norms CENTC 169, and are based more on experience than on scientific knowledge.

          Figure 1. Levels of illumination as a function of tasks performed

          LIG021T1

          The level of illumination is measured with a luxometer that converts luminous energy into an electrical signal, which is then amplified and offers an easy reading on a calibrated scale of lux. When selecting a certain level of illumination for a particular work station the following points should be studied:

          • the nature of the work
          • reflectance of the object and of the immediate surroundings
          • differences with natural light and the need for daytime illumination
          • the worker’s age.

           

          Units and magnitudes of illumination

          Several magnitudes are commonly used in the field of illumination. The basic ones are:

          Luminous flux: Luminous energy emitted per unit of time by a light source. Unit: lumen (lm).

          Luminous intensity: Luminous flux emitted in a given direction by a light that is not equally distributed. Unit: candela (cd).

          Level of illumination: Level of illumination of a surface of one square metre when it receives a luminous flux of one lumen. Unit: lux = lm/m2.

          Luminance or photometric brilliance: Is defined for a surface in a particular direction, and is the relation between luminous intensity and the surface seen by an observer situated in the same direction (apparent surface). Unit: cd/m2.

          Contrast: Difference in luminance between an object and its surroundings or between different parts of an object.

          Reflectance: Proportion of light that is reflected by a surface. It is a non-dimensional quantity. Its value ranges between 0 and 1.

          Factors that affect the visibility of objects

          The degree of safety with which a task is executed depends, in large part, on the quality of illumination and on visual capacities. The visibility of an object can be altered in many ways. One of the most important is the contrast of luminances due to reflection factors, to shadows, or to colours of the object itself, and to the reflection factors of colour. What the eye really perceives are the differences of luminance between an object and its surroundings, or between different parts of the same object. Table 1 lists the contrasts between colours in descending order.

          The luminance of an object, of its surroundings, and of the work area influence the ease with which an object is seen. It is therefore of key importance that the area where the visual task is performed, and its surroundings, be carefully analysed.

          Table 1. Colour contrasts

          Colour contrasts in descending order

          Colour of the object

          Colour of the background

          Black

          Yellow

          Green

          White

          Red

          White

          Blue

          White

          White

          Blue

          Black

          White

          Yellow

          Black

          White

          Red

          White

          Green

          White

          Black

           

          The size of the object that must be observed, which may be adequate or not depending on the distance and the angle of vision of the observer, is another factor. These last two factors determine the arrangement of the work station, classifying different zones according to their ease of vision. We can establish five zones in the work area (see figure 2).

          Figure 2. Distribution of visual zones in the work station

          LIG021F1

          Another factor is the time frame during which vision occurs. The time of exposure will be greater or smaller depending on whether the object and the observer are static, or whether one or both of them are moving. The adaptive capacity of the eye to adjust automatically to the different illuminations of objects can also have considerable influence on visibility.

           

           

           

           

           

           

           

           

           

           

          Light distribution; glare

          Key factors in the conditions that affect vision are the distribution of light and the contrast of luminances. In so far as the distribution of light is concerned, it is preferable to have good general illumination instead of localized illumination in order to avoid glare. For this reason, electrical accessories should be distributed as uniformly as possible in order to avoid differences in luminous intensity. Constant shuttling through zones that are not uniformly illuminated causes eye fatigue, and with time this can lead to reduced visual output.

          Glare is produced when a brilliant source of light is present in the visual field; the result is a diminution in the capacity to distinguish objects. Workers who suffer the effects of glare constantly and successively can suffer from eye strain as well as from functional disorders, even though in many cases they are not aware of it.

          Glare can be direct when its origin is bright sources of light directly in the line of vision, or by reflection when light is reflected on surfaces with high reflectance. The factors involved in glare are:

          1. Luminance of the source of light: The maximum tolerable lumi nance by direct observation is 7,500 cd/m2. Figure 3 shows some of the approximate values of luminance for several sources of light.
          2. Location of the source of light: This kind of glare occurs when the source of light is within a 45-degree angle of the observer’s line of sight, and will be minimized to the degree that the source of light is placed beyond that angle. Ways and methods of avoiding direct and reflective glare can be seen in the following figures (see figure 4).

           

          Figure 3. Approximate values of luminance

          LIG021T3

          Figure 4. Factors that affect glare

          LIG021F2

          In general, there is more glare when sources of light are mounted at lower elevations or when installed in large rooms, because sources of light in large rooms or sources of light that are too low can easily fall within the angle of vision that produces glare.

           

           

           

           

           

           

           

           

           

           

          3. Distribution of luminance among different objects and surfaces: The greater the differences in luminance are among the objects within the field of vision, the greater will be the glare created and the greater will be the deterioration in the capacity to see due to the effects on the adaptive processes of sight. The maximum recommended luminance disparities are:

          • visual task—work surface: 3:1
          • visual task—surroundings: 10:1

           

          4. Time frame of the exposure: Even light sources with a low luminance can cause glare if the length of the exposure is prolonged too much.

          Avoiding glare is a relatively simple proposition and can be achieved in different ways. One way, for example, is by placing grilles under the sources of illumination, or by using enveloping diffusers or parabolic reflectors that can direct light properly, or by installing the sources of light in such a way that they will not interfere with the angle of vision. When designing the work site, the correct distribution of luminance is as important as the illumination itself, but it is also important to consider that a distribution of luminance that is too uniform makes the three-dimensional and spatial perception of objects more difficult.

          Lighting Systems

          The interest in natural illumination has increased recently. This is due less to the quality of illumination it affords than to the well-being that it provides. But since the level of illumination from natural sources is not uniform, an artificial lighting system is required.

          The most common lighting systems used are the following:

          General uniform illumination

          In this system light sources are spread out evenly without regard to the location of the work stations. The average level of illumination should be equal to the level of illumination required for the task that will be carried out. These systems are used mainly in workplaces where work stations are not fixed.

          It should conform to three fundamental characteristics: The first is to be equipped with anti-glare devices (grilles, diffusers, reflectors and so on). The second is that it should distribute a fraction of the light toward the ceiling and the upper part of the walls. And the third is that the light sources should be installed as high as possible, to minimize glare and achieve illumination that is as homogeneous as possible. (See figure 5)

          Figure 5. Lighting systems

          LIG021F3

          This system tries to reinforce the general illumination scheme by placing lamps close to the work surfaces. These types of lamps often produce glare, and reflectors should be placed in such a way that they block the source of light from the direct sight of the worker. The use of localized illumination is recommended for those applications where visual demands are very critical, such as levels of illumination of 1,000 lux or greater. Generally, visual capacity deteriorates with the age of the worker, which makes it necessary to increase the level of general illumination or to second it with localized illumination. This phenomenon can be clearly appreciated in figure 6.

          Figure 6. Loss of visual acuity with age

          LIG021F4

          General localized illumination

          This type of illumination consists of ceiling sources distributed with two things in mind—the illumination characteristics of the equipment and the illumination needs of each work station. This type of illumination is indicated for those spaces or work areas that will require a high level of illumination, and it requires knowing the future location of each work station in advance of the design stage.

          Colour: Basic Concepts

          Selecting an adequate colour for a worksite contributes a great deal to the efficiency, safety and general well-being of the employees. In the same way, the finish of the surfaces and of the equipment found in the work environment contributes to creating pleasant visual conditions and a pleasant work environment.

          Ordinary light consists of electromagnetic radiations of different wavelengths that correspond to each of the bands of the visible spectrum. By mixing red, yellow and blue light we can obtain most of the visible colours, including white. Our perception of the colour of an object depends on the colour of the light with which it is illuminated and on the way the object itself reflects light.

          Lamps can be classified into three categories depending on the appearance of the light they emit:

          • colour with a warm appearance: a white, reddish light recommended for residential use
          • colour with intermediate appearance: a white light recommended for worksites
          • colour with a cold appearance: a white, bluish light recommended for tasks that require a high level of illumination or for hot climates.

           

          Colours may also be classified as warm or cold according to their tonality (see figure 7).

          Figure 7. Tonality of "warm" and "cold" colours

          LIG021F5

          Contrast and temperature of different colours

          Colour contrasts are influenced by the colour of the light selected, and for that reason the quality of illumination will depend on the colour of the light chosen for an application. The selection of the colour of light to be used should be made based on the task that will be carried out under it. If the colour is close to white, the rendition of colour and the diffusion of light will be better. The more light approaches the red end of the spectrum the worse the reproduction of colour will be, but the environment will be warmer and more inviting.

          The colour appearance of illumination depends not only on the colour of light, but also on the level of luminous intensity. A colour temperature is associated with the different forms of illumination. The sensation of satisfaction with the illumination of a given environment depends on this colour temperature. In this way, for example, a 100 W incandescent filament light bulb has a colour temperature of 2,800 K, a fluorescent tube has a colour temperature of 4,000 K and an overcast sky has a colour temperature of 10,000 K.

          Kruithof defined, through empirical observations, a diagram of well-being for different levels of illumination and colour temperatures in a given environment (see figure 8). In this way, he demonstrated that it is possible to feel comfortable in certain environments with low levels of illumination if the colour temperature is also low—if the level of illumination is one candle, for example, with a colour temperature of 1,750 K.

          Figure 8. Comfort diagram as a function of illumination and colour temperatures

          LIG021F6

          The colours of electric lamps can be subdivided into three groups related to their colour temperatures:

          • daylight white—around 6,000 K
          • neutral white—around 4,000 K
          • warm white—around 3,000 K

           

          Combination and selection of colours

          The selection of colours is very relevant when we consider it together with those functions where identifying the objects that must be manipulated is important. It is also relevant when delimiting avenues of communication and in those tasks that require sharp contrast.

          The selection of tonality is not as important a question as the selection of the proper reflective qualities of a surface. There are several recommendations that apply to this aspect of work surfaces:

          Ceilings: The surface of a ceiling should be as white as possible (with a reflection factor of 75%), because light will then reflect from it in a diffuse way, dissipating darkness and reducing the glare from other surfaces. This will also mean a savings in artificial lighting.

          Walls and floors: The surfaces of walls at eye level can produce glare. Pale colours with reflective factors of 50 to 75% tend to be adequate for walls. While glossy paints tend to last longer than matte colours, they are more reflective. Walls should therefore have a matte or semi-gloss finish.

          Floors should be finished in slightly darker colours than walls and ceilings to avoid glare. The reflective factor of floors should be between 20 and 25%.

          Equipment: Work surfaces, machinery and tables should have reflective factors of between 20 and 40%. Equipment should have a lasting finish of pure colour—light browns or greys—and the material should not be shiny.

          The proper use of colours in the work environment facilitates well-being, increases productivity and can have a positive impact on quality. It can also contribute to better organization and the prevention of accidents.

          There is a generalized belief that whitening the walls and ceilings and supplying adequate levels of illumination is all that can possibly be done as far as the visual comfort of employees is concerned. But these comfort factors can be improved by combining white with other colours, thus avoiding the fatigue and the boredom that characterize monochromatic environments. Colours also have an effect on a person’s level of stimulation; warm colours tend to activate and relax, while cold colours are used to induce the individual to release or liberate his or her energy.

          The colour of light, its distribution, and the colours used in a given space are, among others, key factors that influence the sensations a person feels. Given the many colours and comfort factors that exist, it is impossible to set precise guidelines, especially considering that all these factors must be combined according to the characteristics and the requirements of a particular work station. A number of basic and general practical rules can be listed, however, that can help create a liveable environment:

          • Bright colours produce comfortable, stimulating and serene feelings, while dark colours tend to have a depressing effect.
          • Sources of warm-coloured light help reproduce warm colours well. Warm-coloured objects are more pleasing to the eye in warm light than in cold light.
          • Clear and dull colours (like pastels) are very appropriate as background colours, while objects should have rich and saturated colours.
          • Warm colours excite the nervous system and give the sensation that temperature is rising.
          • Cold colours are preferable for objects. They have a calming effect and can be used to produce the effect of curvature. Cold colours help create the sensation that temperature is dropping.
          • The sensation of colour of an object depends on the background colour and on the effect of the light source on its surface.
          • Environments that are physically cold or hot can be tempered by using warm or cold lighting, respectively.
          • The intensity of a colour will be inversely proportional to the part of the normal visual field that it occupies.
          • The spatial appearance of a room can be influenced by colour. A room will seem to have a lower ceiling if its walls are painted a bright colour and the floor and ceiling are darker, and it will seem to have a higher ceiling if the walls are darker and the ceiling is bright.

           

          Identifying objects through colour

          The selection of colours can influence the effectiveness of lighting systems by influencing the fraction of light that is reflected. But colour also plays a key role when it comes to identifying objects. We can use brilliant and eye-catching colours or colour contrasts to highlight situations or objects that require special attention. Table 2 lists some of the factors of reflection for different colours and materials.

          Table 2. Reflection factors of different colours and  materials illuminated with white light

          Colour/material

          Reflection factor (%)

          White

          100

          White paper

          80–85

          Ivory, lime-yellow

          70–75

          Bright yellow, light ochre, light green, pastel blue, light pink, cream

          60–65

          Lime-green, pale gray, pink, orange, blue-gray

          50–55

          Blond wood, blue sky

          40–45

          Oak, dry concrete

          30–35

          Deep red, leaf-green, olive-green, meadow-green

          20–25

          Dark blue, purple

          10–15

          Black

          0

           

          In any case, identification by colour should be employed only when it is truly necessary, since identification by colour will work properly only if there are not too many objects that are highlighted by colour. The following are some recommendations for identifying different elements by colour:

          • Fire and safety equipment: It is advisable to identify this equipment by placing a recognizable graphic on the nearest wall so that it can be found quickly.
          • Machinery: The colouring of stop or emergency devices with bright colours on all machinery is critical. It is also advisable to mark with colour the areas that need lubrication or periodic maintenance, which can add ease and functionality to these procedures.
          • Tubing and pipes: If they are important or carry dangerous substances the best advice is to colour them completely. In some cases it may be enough to colour only a line along their length.
          • Stairways: In order to make descent easier, one band for every step is preferable to several.
          • Risks: Colour should be used to identify a risk only when the risk cannot be eliminated. Identification will be much more effective if it is carried out according to a predetermined colour code.

           

          Back

          Page 95 of 122

          " DISCLAIMER: The ILO does not take responsibility for content presented on this web portal that is presented in any language other than English, which is the language used for the initial production and peer-review of original content. Certain statistics have not been updated since the production of the 4th edition of the Encyclopaedia (1998)."

          Contents

          Chemical Processing References

          Adams, WV, RR Dingman, and JC Parker. 1995. Dual gas sealing technology for pumps. Proceedings 12th International Pump Users Symposium. March, College Station, TX.

          American Petroleum Institute (API). 1994. Shaft Sealing Systems for Centrifugal Pumps. API Standard 682. Washington, DC: API.

          Auger, JE. 1995. Build a proper PSM program from the ground-up. Chemical Engineering Progress 91:47-53.

          Bahner, M. 1996. Level-measurement tools keep tank contents where they belong. Environmental Engineering World 2:27-31.

          Balzer, K. 1994. Strategies for developing biosafety programs in biotechnology facilities. Presented at the 3rd National Symposium on Biosafety, 1 March, Atlanta, GA.

          Barletta, T, R Bayle, and K Kennelley. 1995. TAPS storage tank bottom: Fitted with improved connection. Oil & Gas Journal 93:89-94.

          Bartknecht, W. 1989. Dust Explosions. New York: Springer-Verlag.

          Basta, N. 1994. Technology lifts the VOC cloud. Chemical Engineering 101:43-48.

          Bennett, AM. 1990. Health Hazards in Biotechnology. Salisbury, Wiltshire, UK: Division of Biologics, Public Health Laboratory Service, Centre for Applied Microbiology and Research.

          Berufsgenossenschaftlices Institut für Arbeitssicherheit (BIA). 1997. Measurement of Hazardous Substances: Determination of Exposure to Chemical and Biological Agents. BIA Working Folder. Bielefeld: Erich Schmidt Verlag.

          Bewanger, PC and RA Krecter. 1995. Making safety data “safe”. Chemical Engineering 102:62-66.

          Boicourt, GW. 1995. Emergency relief system (ERS) design: An integrated approach using DIERS methodology. Process Safety Progress 14:93-106.

          Carroll, LA and EN Ruddy. 1993. Select the best VOC control strategy. Chemical Engineering Progress 89:28-35.

          Center for Chemical Process Safety (CCPS). 1988. Guidelines for Safe Storage and Handling of High Toxic Hazard Materials. New York: American Institute of Chemical Engineers.

          —. 1993. Guidelines for Engineering Design for Process Safety. New York: American Institute of Chemical Engineers.
          Cesana, C and R Siwek. 1995. Ignition behavior of dusts meaning and interpretation. Process Safety Progress 14:107-119.

          Chemical and Engineering News. 1996. Facts and figures for the chemical industry. C&EN (24 June):38-79.

          Chemical Manufacturers Association (CMA). 1985. Process Safety Management (Control of Acute Hazards). Washington, DC: CMA.

          Committee on Recombinant DNA Molecules, Assembly of Life Sciences, National Research Council, National Academy of Sciences. 1974. Letter to the editor. Science 185:303.

          Council of the European Communities. 1990a. Council Directive of 26 November 1990 on the protection of workers from risks related to exposure to biological agents at work. 90/679/EEC. Official Journal of the European Communities 50(374):1-12.

          —. 1990b. Council Directive of 23 April 1990 on the deliberate release into the environment of genetically modified organisms. 90/220/EEC. Official Journal of the European Communities 50(117): 15-27.

          Dow Chemical Company. 1994a. Dow’s Fire & Explosion Index Hazard Classification Guide, 7th edition. New York: American Institute of Chemical Engineers.

          —. 1994b. Dow’s Chemical Exposure Index Guide. New York: American Institute of Chemical Engineers.

          Ebadat, V. 1994. Testing to assess your powder’s fire and explosion hazards. Powder and Bulk Engineering 14:19-26.
          Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). 1996. Proposed guidelines for ecological risk assessment. Federal Register 61.

          Fone, CJ. 1995. The application of innovation and technology to the containment of shaft seals. Presented at the First European Conference on Controlling Fugitive Emissions from Valves, Pumps, and Flanges, 18-19 October, Antwerp.

          Foudin, AS and C Gay. 1995. Introduction of genetically engineered microorganisms into the environment: Review under USDA, APHIS regulatory authority. In Engineered Organisms in Environmental Settings: Biotechnological and Agricultural Applications, edited by MA Levin and E Israeli. Boca Raton, FL:CRC Press.

          Freifelder, D (ed.). 1978. The controversy. In Recombinant DNA. San Francisco, CA: WH Freeman.

          Garzia, HW and JA Senecal. 1996. Explosion protection of pipe systems conveying combustible dusts or flammable gases. Presented at the 30th Loss Prevention Symposium, 27 February, New Orleans, LA.

          Green, DW, JO Maloney, and RH Perry (eds.). 1984. Perry’s Chemical Engineer’s Handbook, 6th edition. New York: McGraw-Hill.

          Hagen, T and R Rials. 1994. Leak-detection method ensures integrity of double bottom storage tanks. Oil & Gas Journal (14 November).

          Ho, M-W. 1996. Are current transgenic technologies safe? Presented at the Workshop on Capacity Building in Biosafety for Developing Countries, 22-23 May, Stockholm.

          Industrial Biotechnology Association. 1990. Biotechnology in Perspective. Cambridge, UK: Hobsons Publishing plc.

          Industrial Risk Insurers (IRI). 1991. Plant Layout and Spacing for Oil and Chemical Plants. IRI Information Manual 2.5.2. Hartford, CT: IRI.

          International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection (ICNIRP). In press. Practical Guide for Safety in the Use of RF Dielectric Heaters and Sealers. Geneva: ILO.

          Lee, SB and LP Ryan. 1996. Occupational health and safety in the biotechnology industry: A survey of practicing professionals. Am Ind Hyg Assoc J 57:381-386.

          Legaspi, JA and C Zenz. 1994. Occupational health aspects of pesticides: Clinical and hygienic principles. In Occupational Medicine, 3rd edition, edited by C Zenz, OB Dickerson, and EP Horvath. St. Louis: Mosby-Year Book, Inc.

          Lipton, S and JR Lynch. 1994. Handbook of Health Hazard Control in the Chemical Process Industry. New York: John Wiley & Sons.

          Liberman, DF, AM Ducatman, and R Fink. 1990. Biotechnology: Is there a role for medical surveillance? In Bioprocessing Safety: Worker and Community Safety and Health Considerations. Philadelphia, PA: American Society for Testing and Materials.

          Liberman, DF, L Wolfe, R Fink, and E Gilman. 1996. Biological safety considerations for environmental release of transgenic organisms and plants. In Engineered Organisms in Environmental Settings: Biotechnological and Agricultural Applications, edited by MA Levin and E Israeli. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.

          Lichtenstein, N and K Quellmalz. 1984. Flüchtige Zersetzungsprodukte von Kunststoffen I: ABS-Polymere. Staub-Reinhalt 44(1):472-474.

          —. 1986a. Flüchtige Zersetzungsprodukte von Kunststoffen II: Polyethylen. Staub-Reinhalt 46(1):11-13.

          —. 1986b. Flüchtige Zersetzungsprodukte von Kunststoffen III: Polyamide. Staub-Reinhalt 46(1):197-198.

          —. 1986c. Flüchtige Zersetzungsprodukte von Kunststoffen IV: Polycarbonate. Staub-Reinhalt 46(7/8):348-350.

          Massachusetts Biotechnology Council Community Relations Committee. 1993. Unpublished statistics.

          Mecklenburgh, JC. 1985. Process Plant Layout. New York: John Wiley & Sons.

          Miller, H. 1983. Report on the World Health Organization Working Group on Health Implications of Biotechnology. Recombinant DNA Technical Bulletin 6:65-66.

          Miller, HI, MA Tart and TS Bozzo. 1994. Manufacturing new biotech products: Gains and growing pains. J Chem Technol Biotechnol 59:3-7.

          Moretti, EC and N Mukhopadhyay. 1993. VOC control: Current practices and future trends. Chemical Engineering Progress 89:20-26.

          Mowrer, DS. 1995. Use quantitative analysis to manage fire risk. Hydrocarbon Processing 74:52-56.

          Murphy, MR. 1994. Prepare for EPA’s risk management program rule. Chemical Engineering Progress 90:77-82.

          National Fire Protection Association (NFPA). 1990. Flammable and Combustible Liquid. NFPA 30. Quincy, MA: NFPA.

          National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH). 1984. Recommendations for Control of Occupational Safety and Health Hazards. Manufacture of Paint and Allied Coating Products. DHSS (NIOSH) Publication No. 84-115. Cincinnati, OH: NIOSH.

          National Institute of Health (Japan). 1996. Personal communication.

          National Institutes of Health (NIH). 1976. Recombinant DNA research. Federal Register 41:27902-27905.

          —. 1991. Recombinant DNA research actions under the guidelines. Federal Register 56:138.

          —. 1996. Guidelines for research involving recombinant DNA molecules. Federal Register 61:10004.

          Netzel, JP. 1996. Seal technology: A control for industrial pollution. Presented at the 45th Society of Tribologists and Lubrication Engineers Annual Meetings. 7-10 May, Denver.

          Nordlee, JA, SL Taylor, JA Townsend, LA Thomas, and RK Bush. 1996. Identification of a Brazil-nut allergen in transgenic soybeans. New Engl J Med 334 (11):688-692.

          Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA). 1984. 50 FR 14468. Washington, DC: OSHA.

          —. 1994. CFR 1910.06. Washington, DC:OSHA.

          Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP). 1986. Coordinated Framework for Biotechnology Regulation. FR 23303. Washington, DC: OSTP.

          Openshaw, PJ, WH Alwan, AH Cherrie, and FM Record. 1991. Accidental infection of laboratory worker with recombinant vaccinia virus. Lancet 338.(8764):459.

          Parliament of the European Communities. 1987. Treaty Establishing a Single Council and a Single Commission of the European Communities. Official Journal of the European Communities 50(152):2.

          Pennington, RL. 1996. VOC and HAP control operations. Separations and Filtration Systems Magazine 2:18-24.

          Pratt, D and J May. 1994. Agricultural occupational medicine. In Occupational Medicine, 3rd edition, edited by C Zenz, OB Dickerson, and EP Horvath. St. Louis: Mosby-Year Book, Inc.

          Reutsch, C-J and TR Broderick. 1996. New biotechnology legislation in the European Community and Federal Republic of Germany. Biotechnology.

          Sattelle, D. 1991. Biotechnology in perspective. Lancet 338:9,28.

          Scheff, PA and RA Wadden. 1987. Engineering Design for Control of Workplace Hazards. New York: McGraw-Hill.

          Siegell, JH. 1996. Exploring VOC control options. Chemical Engineering 103:92-96.

          Society of Tribologists and Lubrication Engineers (STLE). 1994. Guidelines for Meeting Emission Regulations for Rotating Machinery with Mechanical Seals. STLE Special Publication SP-30. Park Ridge, IL: STLE.

          Sutton, IS. 1995. Integrated management systems improve plant reliability. Hydrocarbon Processing 74:63-66.

          Swiss Interdisciplinary Committee for Biosafety in Research and Technology (SCBS). 1995. Guidelines for Work with Genetically Modified Organisms. Zurich: SCBS.

          Thomas, JA and LA Myers (eds.). 1993. Biotechnology and Safety Assessment. New York: Raven Press.

          Van Houten, J and DO Flemming. 1993. Comparative analysis of current US and EC biosafety regulations and their impact on the industry. Journal of Industrial Microbiology 11:209-215.

          Watrud, LS, SG Metz, and DA Fishoff. 1996. Engineered plants in the environment. In Engineered Organisms in Environmental Settings: Biotechnological and Agricultural Applications, edited by M Levin and E Israeli. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.

          Woods, DR. 1995. Process Design and Engineering Practice. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.